Uncategorized

Turkish pro-Hamas detainee has 13 lawyers for VT hearing

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

By Michael Donoghue, Vermont News First

An earlier version of this story appeared in the Caledonian-Record.

A Federal judge in Vermont said Monday a Tufts University graduate student from Turkey who was taken off the streets of Somerville, Mass by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement last month will remain in custody for at least another week while her legal battle plays out.

Rumeysa Ozturk, 30, who is in America on a student visa, is currently detained at the Southern Louisiana Correctional Facility in Basile, Louisiana in a case that has drawn international attention for Free Speech reasons.

Ozturk maintains that she is facing possible deportation because she was one of five co-authors of an opinion piece that appeared in the Tufts Daily, the student newspaper at the university outside Boston. It appears the other four co-authors have not been impacted.

The Op-Ed criticized Tufts officials for their response that the university “acknowledge the Palestinian genocide” and divest from companies with ties to Israel.

Senior Federal Judge William K. Sessions III said during a noon-hour hearing that several issues need to be considered, including whether the federal court in Vermont has jurisdiction in the case.

He said that once that is determined, other issues, including whether she will be allowed bail, will be considered.

Six law enforcement officers in plain clothes, all believed to be ICE Agents, picked Ozturk up off the street at about 5:15 p.m. on March 25. After two quick stops in Massachusetts, she headed north to Lebanon, N.H. and eventually to an ICE field office in St. Albans, where she stayed overnight.

Records show that the following morning, Ozturk was flown out of Patrick J. Leahy International Airport in South Burlington at 5:31 a.m., arrived in Louisiana at 2:35 p.m. and was jailed.

By the time her lawyers filed a petition in federal court in Boston, Ozturk was no longer in Massachusetts, and that court appeared to have no authority over the case.

Sessions gave lawyers for Ozturk and the government until 5 p.m. Thursday to file legal briefs on several issues. He said he is prepared to hear arguments on Monday and also on Tuesday if necessary.

Before making the offer for a hearing on Monday, Sessions was scheduled for seven major hearings, including two sentencings between 9:30 a.m. and 4 p.m.

According to court records, Ozturk has a legal team of at least 13 named lawyers. They include out-of-state immigration lawyers and American Civil Liberties Union members in Massachusetts and Vermont.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Michael Sauter of Boston started with the case when it was filed in Massachusetts, but during the noon-hour hearing on Monday, only Acting U.S. Attorney for Vermont Michael P. Drescher spoke.

Ozturk will remain in the United States pending the outcome of the legal fight.

Ozturk wants the court to have jurisdiction in the case and declare that her detention violates the Due Process clause of the Fifth Amendment, Sessions said.

Sessions noted several filings in the case are based on the First Circuit Court of Appeals, which includes Massachusetts. The judge said the case is now in Vermont, which is part of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.

Drescher agreed that the legal arguments for Ozturk’s case should be based on the past rulings by the Second Circuit appeals court based in New York City.

Ozturk’s lead lawyer Ramzi Kassem said he wanted to ensure that the case was heard promptly, a promise Sessions provided.

Sessions said he considers it a “really unique case.”

Kasssem also argued that Ozturk should not be considered a flight risk. He noted that she has about two dozen letters of support from friends. He said she wants to return to her classes at Tufts and complete her course of study.

Sessions said detention or release would be considered after a determination is made about jurisdiction.

Drescher said the case could be handled through the normal Immigration process.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio has said he moved to revoke Ozturk’s student visa on March 21 and made her subject for legal removal.


Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Categories: Uncategorized

10 replies »

  1. OK…….lets name these birds straight off the court documents and start our hunt for an explanation….right here in good old green VT

  2. Who’s paying for all those lawyers! It better not be the taxpayers!

    • The whole world sees the genocide of the Palestinians being committed by Israel. As for October 7, an occupied people, as the Palestinians have been for three-four generations now, have the right under international law to resist the occupiers who have stolen their land. Your ignorance of the history is breathtaking, but perhaps you don’t want to face the truth. Hamas did not even exist until the 1980’s and it has also been partially financially supported by Natanyahu and his cohorts in the past. There will be one state in Judea where Muslims, Christians and Jews can live in freedom, equality and harmony. Zionist control of the US government will not last forever.

  3. Standing against genocide to which the USA is a party because we supply the weapons is not pro-Hamas, it is pro-humanity. Americans, you are being conned.

    • Israel is not committing Genocide! Hamas is! Hamas attacked Israel first from Palestine! So they aimed back and have been fighting Hamas not the Palestinians. What about the people killed in Israel. I guess they don’t count! Maybe the Palestinians need to fight back against Hamas with Israel! That’s a novel idea. You people are so ignorant!

  4. In 1770, John Adams defended the British soldiers involved in the Boston Massacre. I am sure the MAGAs in those days branded him as unpatriotic and probably objected to his being compensated for services rendered. Fortunately, we are a nation of LAWS.

  5. what NGO is paying for all these lawyers! cut off all taxpayer money flowing to these NGOs

  6. Thirteen lawyers, very interesting. Someone has a lot of money. Those people that support genocide will fair well in the future. How many of you took the COVID KILL SHOT??????????

  7. Billable hours! Good on the ACLU for expending resources on a foreign national and sending American’s cases to the back of the line. Woo hoo – best be getting those greenbacks in haste before the giant rug pull…way to go! RICO is the game-o and they are playing it so well!