Sense of urgency moves restorative justice, abortion/transgender shield bills to head of the line

By Guy Page

When it wants to, the Vermont Legislature can convert a bill into a law very promptly. It has already done so this year with legislation regarding restorative justice, abortion rights, Town Meeting, and other issues.

As of today, only 15 bills passed by the 2023 Vermont Legislature have become full-fledged laws. Of the other 101 passed by both the House and Senate this year, many will become law soon. Others will have to wait until next year. Some may never become laws at all.

Two abortion-related laws were the result of a pro-abortion rights Legislature acting on what it perceived as a mandate from voters’ November 2022 ratification of the Article 22 Constitutional Amendment enshrining abortion rights, and the overturning of Roe V. Wade decision.

A pair of bills pertaining to criminal cases going to restorative justice, diversion and expungement passed as the Legislature sought to help relieve the crowded backlog on the Vermont criminal courts.

Bills passed by the Legislature undergo a lengthy gubernatorial and clerical review process. The following bills are among the 15 bills that have already run that gauntlet to become official Acts of the Legislature:

Act 1(H.42)Allows selectboards to authorize Australian ballot for Town Meeting, and hold public hearings by remote ‘Zoom’
Act 5(H.28)Sets guidelines for court diversion and expungement
Act 8(H.148)Raises age of eligibility to marry to age 18
Act 9(H.35)Changes oversight of the Victims Assistance Program from the Office of Crime Services to the Department of State’s Attorneys and Sheriffs
Act 10(H.190)Removes the residency requirement from Vermont’s patient choice at end of life [a/k/a assisted suicide] laws
Act 11(H.41)Refers domestic and sexual violence cases to community justice centers for ‘restorative justice’
Act 13(S.3)Prohibits paramilitary training camps
Act 14(H.89)Shields abortion/transgender service providers from civil and criminal procedures
Act 15(S.37)Guarantees health care coverage for abortions, shields abortion providers from professional misconduct charges, allows Attorney General to pursue deceptive advertising charges against pregnancy resource centers that do not perform abortions

116 bills passed both the House and the Senate this year. However, not all will become law. In some cases, the two chambers passed different versions of the same bill, requiring reconciliation when the Legislature reconvenes in January. Others may be vetoed successfully by the governor. 

Categories: Legislation

3 replies »

  1. Act 15 (S37) is unconstitutional under Article 22. If the law guarantees health care coverage for abortions and “gender transition”, then it must also guarantee coverage for pregnancy and delivery, and detransitioning; and birth/delivery and detransitioner practitioners must also be shielded.

  2. For many sessions now, the Vermont Legislature has utilized the ramrod method to create laws in a hasty, partisan fashion. The consequences of these “acts” not considered or debated in any significant fashion. The goal achieved is to hold themselves and their co-conspirators harmless, free of liability, free of any comeuppance of torts or criminal acts committed. My bet is a majority of the public has no idea the negative impact such laws will have upon them or their communities. Many likely don’t even know these laws were even introduced or passed. These laws also ensure infinite job security and taxpayer funding to non-profit and NGO organizations. These organizations are comprised of bureaurcrat lackeys and cronies who were front and center to testify and lobby for their own benefit. Any opposition was ignored and subverted. Woe onto them. The day will arrive where new represenation will take hold and begin the long, arduous task to repeal and destroy their evil, destructive lawfare.

    • What I witnessed a couple of weeks ago outside of the chamber re: vote on S.5 was revelatory. The newer/younger female legislators–coiffed to the nines–were behaving like trained seals under the direction of Phil Baruth. In contrast, long-timer Dick Sears strode in unaccompanied, failed to make eye contact and voted accordingly.