|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
By Guy Page
Democratic gubernatorial candidate Amanda Janoo has advocated for “degrowth,” an economic approach that calls for reducing production and consumption in some sectors rather than pursuing economic growth as a primary goal.
Janoo, a Burlington resident, is the Democrat nominee for governor, running against incumbent Republican Phil Scott in the November 3 general election. One September poll (UNH) shows her leading Phil Scott, another (Vermont Public) shows her trailing him. Scott, by contrast, has supported legislation and policies creating more housing, population, and economic growth.
In a June 22, 2023 interview with the Overpopulation Podcast, published on YouTube, Janoo, then economics and policy lead for the Wellbeing Economy Alliance, described degrowth as part of a broader movement seeking to replace economic growth with social and environmental wellbeing as the chief measure of progress.
Janoo criticized the current economic system, saying its primary goal is to increase production, consumption and profits through the “systematic exploitation of people and planet.”
She said the Wellbeing Economy movement includes degrowth, post-growth economics, circular economics and other approaches that challenge traditional capitalism.
“We have to stop treating people and planet like they’re here to serve the economy and start treating the economy like it’s here to serve us,” Janoo said.
Discussing a European conference where degrowth advocates debated ‘green growth’ supporters of environmentally sustainable economic expansion, Janoo explained the difference between the competing approaches.
“The degrowth perspective was quite clear,” she said. “We need to stop growing, right? Like we actually need to decline in a lot of the areas.”
She contrasted that position with “green growth,” which maintains that technological advances and renewable energy investments can allow economic expansion to continue.
Janoo also supported reducing working hours, expanding worker cooperatives and social enterprises, and distributing wealth more equally.
She advocated using government taxes to discourage industries and business practices considered harmful to people or the environment, while providing subsidies and grants to activities deemed beneficial.
Janoo said governments should identify which parts of the economy deserve support and which “we need to also hospice or sunset because they’re very damaging.”
She praised Wales for adopting wellbeing goals that influenced government spending, including a decision to shift transportation funding away from additional highway construction toward public transportation and other alternatives.
Janoo also questioned the influence of corporations and wealthy interests on government policy.
“I’m from the United States, which is probably the most corrupt country in the world. We call it lobbying,” she said. [1:03 mark in YouTube video]
Her proposed economic model would measure success less by gross domestic product and more by health, environmental protection, fairness, community connections and quality of life.
Janoo argued that economic policy should be shaped by public participation rather than conventional assumptions about growth and profitability.
Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Categories: politics
Waiting for the comments. Comment from Richard Day.
“I’m from the United States, which is probably the most corrupt country in the world. We call it lobbying,” [Janoo] said.
I think this specific quote was taken out of context. She was referring to our federal government, corporate kickbacks, payoffs, in the form of lobbying (all evident under our current Trump administration). Janoo wasn’t saying the U.S. is a corrupt nation, but the system is. And I agree with her 100% on this.
Regarding the “degrowth’ economic theory, I think that’s perfect for a state like Vermont that is a state rich in rural resources. You let the corporations come in and the entire state will look like a strip mall, (like Williston off I-89), filled with parking lots and warehouses.
Also remember, this is a video from 3 years ago. I would hope we have all evolved from the people we three years ago. Our ideas and perspectives mature.
But thanks for sharing the video.
Not really. India, as one example, is worse.
Bob, you weren’t around when there was Precision Valley being Springfield & Windsor, most patents (going back into the 1700’s), high employment (Many from Rutland), 8 major industries, The best Machine Cooperative Journeyman’s rating high school program (I was one), best teachers. The course was 4 years ahead of any school in the US, Robert LaBonte was the best instructor by far, great imagination and an administration that allowed him to perform for the students, god rest his soul. No unions, no NEA (fed or state), no lobbyists, but dedicated instructors (I use that term, not “teacher”) that it was)
VT had a great economy and people. It’s all been destroyed, and Janoo seeks to maintain that status given her rhetoric and make it worse.. She’s not from Venus, but another galaxy very far distant. She should hope back on her UFO and depart.
I give thanks to Mr. Labonte many times and visited his grave in deep appreciation who gave me a true meaning of life and to achieve. REALLY. Janoo will never get that respect.
How is public transportation going to work when most people live in the country or off state highways, it’s great for cities but the only two big places big enough to support public transportation is Chittenden county, and Rutland.
“”She advocated using government taxes to discourage industries and business practices considered harmful to people or the environment, while providing subsidies and grants to activities deemed beneficial.””
So, us lowly proletarians are supposed to acquiesce to whatever “government” decides is harmful or beneficial? NOT A CHANCE!
Here’s a short list of Republican use of tax policy to encourage or discourage certain activities:
Really, is she having that time in life when she’s having a menopause attack? And she’s not alone under the golden dome. Totally out of reality. Has to be some reason.
Scientists studied 1 million women before menopause—one pattern stood out
https://www.yahoo.com/health/your-body/womens-health/menopause/articles/scientists-studied-1-million-women-180555439.html
In sober fact, because people disagree with you doesn’t mean that they’re impaired.
Read and look at the record it has a meaning. And I’ve been around the barn quite a few times and when VT was great. Study the facts.
““We have to stop treating people and planet like they’re here to serve the economy and start treating the economy like it’s here to serve us,” Janoo said.”
Word salad.
Janoo is a dreamer with no relevance to reality. Ever notice that when the economy declines (the one that serves us), people no longer give two craps about the ecosystem or climate change? It’s called reality — people want to feed and house themselves. It is as old as humanity: Marxism, however, is not — it is a uniquely modern failure.
Ooh boy; would LOVE to see her list of industries that her government would protect, and which industries her government would strangle with an exercise band. Now THAT is socialist Central Planning!! Sorry toots, the USSR died for a reason!!
Janoo is equal to voodoo. The day before August 11th primary she ran down to consult with Mandami in NYC. Says it all. Look what has happened to NY City, look what has happened to Burlington, VT. Once the demoncrats get their stronghold in place, the real citizens, homeowners and workers are neglected & unheard. How many times has Burlington requested aid, help, $$ to undo the horror that has happened. Let’s all please vote with forethought and not hindsight.
That’s one small step for man, one giant leap backwards for mankind. The end.
Vermont has the lowest GDP in the Union
and the 5th highest per capita tax burden.
Those two number are wed to one another and are not sustainable
and need to be reconciled.
DeGrowth of any form would only exacerbate the gap .
instead of 12 seasons in Vermont
We’d have only one …..Mud Season year round
Well thats from a Woman that has worked for the UN as well as international NGOs that accomplish nothing but patting themselves on the back.
And she is a Dem/lib and ensconced in the most corrupt party in US history.
Given her involvement with Dems that is all she sees.
She will be the first “king” of the first colony of the United Nations! Vermont is the first colony! What do the no kings people have to say. She is completely a United Nations plant, therefore I predict she will win this election, regardless of how people vote.
Re: Janoo backs ‘degrowth,’ calls for less production, consumption in new economic model
I thought they were progressive, but they are regressive.
Degrowth or depopulation?
‘What specific projects did Amanda Janoo lead at the United Nations Industrial Development Organization?’
Search assist’s response: Sorry, no relevant information was found in our search.
She’s not a democrat she is to scared to put the DSA after the name democrat.
The working class and elderly can die off. Only well-to-do Socialists who are enlightened allowed.
I told ya’s a while back. This is their playground.
The U.S. Census Bureau projects that Vermont’s population will not change (actually, it might decrease slightly) between now and 2030.
So it’s a waste of public money to continue government subsidies for development and housing. And to increase the liquidation of our natural assets so as to subsidize more real estate development is wasteful, too.
Stop listening to fearmongers and snake-oil salesmen.
This janoo idiot is pushing ‘circular flow’ economics which is gobbledygook for COMMUNISM, where the government is responsible for taxing the population to spend that money on the population…..
You need to heed this warning: janoo is your MORTAL ENEMY!!!! The wolf in sheep’s clothing. So indoctrinated she will live, breathe, propagate and force her (evil) dream upon you and demand your thanks and worship….. this is the enemy at the gates people, your worst nightmare possible, satan with a lying smile and fingers crossed behind his back with cash in hand in front of you….. she is the nuclear end of Vermont. Treat her as the blood enemy she is.