By Michael Donoghue, Vermont News First
The Winooski School Board may have violated Vermont’s Open Meeting Law on Friday in its rush to issue a statement questioning an education answer Gov. Phil Scott gave during a debate earlier this week.
Under Vermont law a government board can only take action during a publicly warned meeting.
There was no known meeting — regular, special or emergency — listed in the past few days on the Winooski School District website. Notices have to be posted in advance at multiple sites, including the school website, according to the Vermont Open Meeting Law.
WCAX-TV in South Burlington hosted the televised debate on Wednesday night.
The School Board issued its public statement on Friday, including posting it on Facebook.
No live person answered the phone at the Winooski School District office on Friday afternoon and there was no response made to the voice message left.
Winooski Board President Nicole Mace and Vice-President Robert Millar were asked in an email when was the meeting held, who participated and what was the vote.
Mace and Millar never responded to two email messages each received on Friday from Vermont News First.
Open Meeting Law training is available for School Board members each year.
The statement attributed to the Winooski School Board said Scott suggested the Winooski School District offers 17 language classes. The board said that was incorrect.
The board statement said Superintendent Wilmer Chavarria wrote on Thursday to Secretary of Education Zoie Saunders asking that the record be corrected.
The School Board did not say why Chavarria did not reach out to Scott directly.
The School Board said Saunders initially replied that the Governor keeps a line between governing and campaigning.
WCAX reported Friday evening that Scott issued an apology for misspeaking and said it came as he was trying to highlight the educational spending differences between some rural and more populated areas.q
The Winooski School Board maintained “We do not raise this lightly, and we are not taking a side in the election.”
The General Election is on Tuesday.
Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.












Penalties for an unauthorized public statement issued without a properly warned meeting include a maximum criminal fine of $500 for individual board members and the invalidation of the statement itself,
The legal procedure for holding the board accountable requires a specific, multi-step process:
1. Submit a Written Notice: Any aggrieved person (or the Vermont Attorney General) must first submit a written notice of the alleged violation directly to the Winooski School Board. This letter must specify the exact violation (e.g., issuing a joint board statement on October 30 without a warned meeting) and request a specific “cure”.
2. The 10-Day Response Window: The school board has 10 calendar days to publicly respond. They must either acknowledge the violation and state an intent to cure it, or state that they believe no violation occurred.
3. The 14-Day Cure Process: If they acknowledge the error, they have 14 calendar days to hold an official, publicly warned open meeting. In that meeting, they must either officially ratify the statement, declare it void, and implement preventative measures to ensure it does not happen again.
4. Filing a Civil Lawsuit: If the board fails to respond, denies the violation, or fails to properly cure it, the aggrieved person or the Attorney General can then sue the board in the Civil Division of the Superior Court (not small claims court) within one year of the incident. The court can issue an injunction, hand down a declaratory judgment, and force the public body to pay the plaintiff’s attorney fees.
The board denies that there are 17 language classes but fails to admit how many actually exist. And yes, the possible violation of the open meeting law must be investigated. So many of these boards believe that they are omnipotent and need to be held to the rule of law. To make such a mountain out of the Governor’s statement, tells me that they are terribly defensive….one has to wonder why.
It literally says that French is the only language offered in the very first sentence of the district’s statement.
There is no violation of Law unless the people in charge of the board identify as GOP
Has there ever been a case where a fine was issued for a violation of this public meeting law?
Vermonts OML is a joke with no repercussions for the violations that occur on an almost daily basis
Why are members of the school board ignorant of the rules? Or do they not care about the rules?
David Dempsey
They believe they are the rule makers, not the rule followers
Was it really an “attack” on Phil Scott or a “statement questioning an education answer”? It can’t be both. Calm down.
-“No live person answered the phone at the Winooski School District office”: Duh, since the end of the COVID panic, when have you ever called a state agency or education bureaucracy and gotten a live human?
-“The School Board did not say why Chavarria did not reach out to Scott directly”: Why would he?, he is a total moonbat, hoping for Scott’s electoral loss.
“The Winooski School Board maintained ‘We do not raise this lightly, and we are not taking a side in the election’. “: No one who pays attention is believing that they are not totally on board with a change to a democrat governor.
The amount of money this district and burlington waste on immigrant education is mind-blowing. The public has ZERO CLUE. Multilingual liaisons, EL departments/teachers (louder and slower). Tiny classes. Co-teaching. And the ROI is definitely a negative. Put these kids in front of a computer with a language program and have them learn English. Can the EL department and all the “liaisons” who do what all day? Giant savings, and the kids will actually assimilate and learn something. Who cares how many languages are offered? Kids coming out of “French IV” don’t know French. JOKE
The governor made a grossly inaccurate statement during a campaign debate with the election only a few days off. So for the school board to correct the misstatement of fact it needs to warn a meeting? Ridiculous. The article should have linked to the school board’s statement on Facebook. Has anyone read it besides myself and Mr. Davis above? If so, what does anyone believe would be different if a meeting had been warned and the matter brought up during said meeting? Nitpicking partisanship poisons the political process, which has already been poisoned enough.
The issue isn’t whether the governor made an inaccurate statement or whether that statement deserved correction. To my knowledge, there was nothing illegal about the governor’s remarks. He made a misstatement, and correcting the record is one thing. How a public board goes about doing so is another.
The reason we have established policies and procedures governing public boards is to prevent conflicts of interest, ensure transparency, protect the appropriate use of taxpayer resources, and avoid even the appearance that public institutions are being used for political purposes. Those safeguards exist for a reason, and they shouldn’t become optional simply because someone believes the political circumstances justify an exception.
If the board overstepped its established procedures in its rush to correct a political statement, that deserves scrutiny, regardless of whether people agree with the correction itself. The appropriate response isn’t to dismiss concerns about procedure as nitpicking or partisanship. It’s to acknowledge that the rules apply even when following them is inconvenient.
When we excuse procedural shortcuts because we agree with the outcome, we establish a precedent that those same shortcuts can be justified by others for entirely different political purposes. That is precisely how public trust erodes.
Public boards have a responsibility to serve the public interest, not to become instruments in the political process. Following established procedures isn’t a technicality to be brushed aside when politically convenient. It’s fundamental to maintaining public confidence that these institutions are acting impartially and in the interests of the people they serve.
Mark Kelley – Not a “misstatement” – a dog whistle. Do you really think that the governor thinks that Winooski offers 17 language classes? The state’s university only offers nine. Not Scott’s style, so you know he’s getting desperate.
@Mark Perrault
Approximately 20 different languages are spoken by students PreK-12 in the Winooski School District, which serves around 300 active or monitored multilingual learner students.
This requires a liaison team of at least eight multi language interpreters.
Languages spoken include but are not limited to, Nepali, Swahili, Somali, Spanish, French, Mai-Mai, Karen, Arabic, Kinyarwanda, Vietnamese, Punjabi, Burmese, and Pashto.
Could this possibly have been what the Governor was referring to?
Labeling it a dog whistle is nothing more than projection on your part.
Matt well done. Well done.
So I heard that our Governor Phil Scott may have made a misnomer? It doesn’t sound like it has felony quality to it. Stop the drama simply request a correction and move on. Stop causing war. I want you to consider the last time you made an error and then why? We are still working on integrity issues. Is this showing up as common? Maybe a sabbatical is in order for everyone.