Scientists say runoff regs don’t factor in phosphorus already in lake
New findings indicate that state and federal regulators hoping to improve water quality in Lake Champlain will need to adjust their policies to address warming temperatures that trigger toxic blue-green algae blooms, according to a research team based at The University of Vermont.
Current water-quality standards focus on levels of phosphorus that run off from farms and other property into rivers that flow into Lake Champlain, but they don’t account for existing phosphorus that has settled into the sediment from previous years, the researchers report in a recent article in Earth’s Future, a prominent publication focused on sustainability. That “legacy” phosphorus lies in wait for warm weather, which creates the ideal oxygen-choked environment for the growth of cyanobacteria, commonly called blue-green algae.
A multidisciplinary team working with the Vermont Established Program to Stimulate Competitive Research, or VT EPSCoR, used a unique modeling method to predict more than 100 potential scenarios of the changing climate – specifically temperature and precipitation – and the consequences for phosphorus-fueled algae that plagues the shallow Missisquoi Bay in Lake Champlain’s northeastern corner. Their computations incorporated current standards set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency in 2015 to reduce the total maximum daily load, or TMDL, of phosphorus running into Missisquoi Bay by 64.3 percent, leaving the water cleaner.
“These indicators do not address, completely, the direct effects of climate change on the warming of the water in the fresh bays and the lakes,” said Asim Zia, a UVM professor of public policy and computer science and the lead author of the recent article, part of a larger study applying these advanced modeling tools to assess the various ways that climate change has consequences for water quality in Lake Champlain.
“Despite these aggressive policy targets, the legacy phosphorus that is already in the lake, in the bay, would offset that reduction and we will continue to see these blooms.”
While the EPA’s standard is helpful, it’s only one piece of the cyanobacteria solution, Zia said. The regulations involve measuring both “external” phosphorus at the runoff point and “internal” phosphorus that settles in the lake. The UVM team recommends two additional criteria — the amount of cyanobacteria growth itself and the number of days that those blooms surpass a certain threshold. A day or two of bursting blooms aren’t serious, Zia suggests, but 10 or more days have crucial consequences for public health and recreation around the lake.
Policymakers can use satellite imagery, drone technology, reports from citizen and scientist observers, or sensors to record algae levels, Zia said. Looking to reduce those levels, scientists are studying aeration technology to increase oxygen in the bottom layers of Lake Carmi in Vermont to mitigate the conditions that cause blooms, an effort led by fellow researcher, Dr. Andrew Schroth, a University of Vermont bio-geochemist.
An updated policy would have benefits far beyond Vermont, Zia said – for any waterway where the TMDL standard applies: parts of the Great Lakes; estuaries of the Gulf Coast and Everglades of Florida; and some areas of the Chesapeake Bay.
The EPA’s current strategy to improve water quality by 2035 – with nutrient levels down to 0.025 micrograms per liter in Missisquoi Bay – should be reconsidered given these new findings, according to the researchers. Zia said “It’s about setting the right expectations for people and the public.”
Some of us have been saying that the P level in alluvial fans will keep the Lake susceptible to algae blooms for a long time – and dredging them out and finding some place to put them is wildly expensive. Old timers may remember in 1972 or so AG James Jeffords made much of stopping paper making waste in the Lake, which everybody agreed with, but insisted that the Lake be dredged to remove untold tons of pollutants buried harmlessly under layers of sediment. Even the EPA balked at that enormously costly plan, and it disappeared, although Jeffords lived on.