|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
by Jarrod Vaillancourt
Over the past couple of years, school districts across the country have increasingly found themselves involved in controversies over policies promoting gender ideology. In some instances, this has been done while violating the constitutional rights of others. School districts and other educational organizations have faced costly litigation and have been required to pay thousands of dollars in legal settlements, judgments, fees and costs to those whose rights were violated and who chose to push back.
Vermont has not been immune to this, as reported in the Vermont Daily Chronicle:
Victimized by transgender activism, some Vermonters pushed back
In a recent case in our region, the Bow School District in neighboring New Hampshire has agreed to a settlement providing $275,000 in legal fees and costs, following a court judgment that the district violated the First Amendment rights of individuals who were prohibited from wearing pink “XX” wristbands at a girls’ high school soccer game in 2024. The wristbands expressed opposition to allowing transgender-identifying males to complete in girls’ sports.
As the court concluded, school officials “cannot favor one side of a debate involving parental speech on an issue of prominent public concern.”
The Institute for Free Speech Senior Attorney added, “This judgment confirms that our clients had a First Amendment right to silently express their views on a major public issue even though school district officials disagreed with their views. We hope this victory will make other school officials think twice before silencing one side of a public debate.”
These cases serve as an important reminder to parents and families throughout Vermont: You do not surrender your constitutional rights when your children enter the public school system. Parents have a right to express their views, raise concerns, and challenge school policies and practices, and should feel empowered to do so.
The full article from the Institute for Free Speech, which led the litigation, can be found here:
Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Categories: Commentary












Jarrod, don’t forget, all the litigation costs we the tax payer are on the hook for as well. On top of the union increases every year for horrible results. The whole system need to be torn down, no more unions. Pay is based on results, always has been, not through forced hands and demands. Anyways, parents need to grow the balls these teachers have to try and tell us what our kids need. Protect your kids from these predators, with the rainbow flags, nose rings, and multi colored hair. The alphabet community wants to transition your kids, its all perverted.
”no more unions. Pay is based on results”
Can we apply this to police departments statewide too?
When the teachers’ union members have to swear an oath on the Constitution, then they can have a union. Other than those Constitutionally sworn, society would be best served by the dissolution of all public-sector unions. They were allowed to form by a JFK executive order and they should be abolished now by similar executive action.
The lawsuits are a positive sign that most thinking people are appalled that the public education system has been turned into a very expensive indoctrination mechanism to teach hatred of our Western values/Judeo-Christian ethics and preach their freaky sexuality and gender expression agenda to a captive audience of impressionable yoots. That and the kids come out with diplomas with minimal basic math and technical skills and a poor grasp of the proper use of the English language. Teachers and other staff should not be protected by any level of qualified immunity to engage in these practices and should be exposed to personal legal liability. Eliminating all public sector unions would be a good place to start ending this national tragedy.
Even the Professional Fire Fighters of Vermont, the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, or the New England Police Benevolent Association?
Those are all public sector unions that support and provide for countless Vermonters, many of whom are likely your friends and neighbors.
The IBEW is private sector David. Big difference from unionized government and teachers unions. Unions are corrupt to the core.
The IBEW public sector unions absolutely represents federal, state, provincial, and municipal government employees, including workers at public utilities (like the Tennessee Valley Authority and Bonneville Power Administration), national laboratories, military installations, and public transit and building maintenance departments.
The IBEW is private sector David. Big difference from unionized government and teachers unions. Unions are corrupt to the core.
David, what happened to the days of merit? Pay based on dedication, hard work, time, etc.? Entitlement moved in, everyone gets a trophy, yeah I pooped today! That is not real life. You shouldn’t be rewarded for being mediocre. I’ve seen how unions work, people are lazy, because they are protected. They have clicks, just like in high school, they are awarded things they may not necessarily have earned, Entitlement. Not to mention, as the employer, your hand is forced. What if you can’t afford it? Can’t lay anyone off, union rights. Keep em on, keep raising wages, benefits, insurance, until there is no company. Vermont is at will employment, unless you’re in a union. Where are my protections, my rights, my guaranteed raises, benefits, cheaper insurance? I’ll tell ya, at the job I work at, where I appreciate, no have the privilege of, supporting my family with the funds I’ve EARNED, worked hard for, built my way up. I didn’t walk in and demand anything and threaten to strike if I didn’t get my way, children do that. When I became a man, I put away foolish things. Unions need to go.
Unions protect bad workers and run counter to a merit-based society. The more hidden agenda of public-sector unions though is their role as money conduits from taxpayers to salaried government employees paying dues to the unions where the unions then support primarily the democrat party with contributions.
I don’t like unions either. However I will still say:
“Even the Professional Fire Fighters of Vermont, the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, or the New England Police Benevolent Association?
Those are all public sector unions that support and provide for countless Vermonters, many of whom are likely your friends and neighbors.”
Mr. Davis, you mention the Professional Fire Fighters of Vermont, the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, and the New England Police Benevolent Association as examples of unions that support and provide a net positive for Vermonters. Could you share specific examples of what these organizations actually provide to the general public, beyond the benefits they secure for their own dues-paying members?
From my perspective, every union represents a usurpation of individual agency. Every employee-employer relationship is fundamentally a direct contract and negotiation: I agree to do specific work, and the employer agrees to compensate me for it. A union inserts an unnecessary layer of bureaucracy right into the middle of that personal negotiation.
Instead of advocating for my own value, I am forced to go through a third party,paying them a fee to negotiate on my behalf, and simply hope they care enough to escalate my concerns to management. Worse, the employer is no longer obligated to satisfy my individual needs; they only have to satisfy the needs of the union.
In a free market, if I don’t like the terms of a compensation plan, I am under no obligation to accept the job. I have the freedom to move on to another employer, or even start my own business to offer a better-quality, lower-cost alternative. That competition is what drives excellence.
Ultimately, unions are small, private organizations that benefit a limited group of individuals, not the general public. In the public sector especially, adding this extra bureaucracy just drives up costs for taxpayers while guaranteeing wages regardless of performance. True capitalism rewards competition and produces the best possible service…guaranteed union contracts do not.
And now after the passage of Prop 3 in Vermont, the union covering an employee doesn’t even have to benefit them but they may still have to pay dues and be a member or not get hired for some jobs. How is that a free speech thing?…sounds like compelled speech to me.
Well David, I still say, disband em all, they too can be hourly employees, the water is fine over here. No special treatment, average pay, and expensive insurance. Come have a taste, see what its like for the rest of us. I don’t care what group they are, earn your pay the old fashion way, hard work, grit, and a bit of pride in a job well done. I may never be rich, but, my family also won’t ever, and I mean ever, call me lazy.