Commentary

Steinerman: How will we remember? Vermont must teach the Holocaust.

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

By Debora Steinerman, Co-founder Vermont Holocaust Memorial

I recently attended the 36th Annual World Federation of Jewish Holocaust Survivors and Descendants Conference, in Philadelphia–perhaps one of the last gatherings to include several Holocaust survivors. Those survivors were very young children when the Nazi persecution of European Jews began. Today, they fear that when their voices are gone, their stories will be forgotten.

As a founder of Vermont Holocaust Memorial, a child of Holocaust survivors (“2G”), and descendant of its victims, I feel a profound responsibility to preserve their legacy. I attended with my daughter, a member of the third generation (“3G”), who is now carrying the mantle of remembrance in her own community. Watching her generation step forward gives me hope, but the urgency of their mission was unmistakable.

Throughout the conference, participants spoke of growing antisemitism, Holocaust denial, and false equivalencies that distort history. They worry that The Holocaust will become a footnote in history books rather than a defining lesson about the consequences of hatred, dehumanization, and indifference.

Eighty-one years after the end of World War II, its effects continue to haunt survivors and their descendants. Conference sessions explored intergenerational trauma, survivor guilt, and a particularly poignant question: “Are We Allowed to Be Happy?” The Holocaust did not end emotionally when the war ended. Its losses reverberate through families, shaping identities and leaving absences that can never be filled.

As we commemorate the 88th anniversary of Kristallnacht, “The Night of Broken Glass,” on November 9–10, I am reminded that history is not something that happened only to others. I grew up with the knowledge that my grandfather, aunts, uncles, and cousins had been murdered simply because they were Jewish. I never had the opportunity to get to know them. Before the war, they were ordinary people: shopkeepers, business-people, homemakers, students, and playful children. They had dreams and futures that were violently taken away.

Their life stories are part of my inheritance. Descendants of Holocaust survivors and victims carry that legacy, whether they recognize it or not. We inherit the memories, the silences, and the responsibility to ensure that those who were murdered are remembered as individuals, not merely as statistics.

Yet remembrance must also inspire hope. At the conference, the 3G participants spoke with resilience, confidence, and joy. They are finding new ways to preserve history, using technology and social media to share their experiences and stand proudly in their Jewish identities. Their voices are a breath of fresh air. They reminded us that honoring the past does not mean surrendering the future.

But hope alone is not enough. We must act.

Vermont remains one of the very few states without a requirement to teach The Holocaust in its secondary schools. Although many dedicated Vermont educators ensure that students learn this history, education should not depend on an individual teacher’s initiative or a school’s priorities.

Every student deserves to learn about Jewish life before, during and after The Holocaust, what happened, and how an “enlightened” society descended into genocide. Students must understand the roles of perpetrators, bystanders, and those who resisted. They need historically accurate, carefully vetted resources that help them recognize antisemitism, challenge propaganda, and distinguish historical fact from deliberate distortion.

Vermont Holocaust Memorial supports educators through annual professional development workshops, exhibits, projects, and a speaker’s bureau. These efforts are invaluable, but they cannot substitute for a consistent statewide commitment.

When Holocaust education is not required, students may graduate without the meaningful understanding of one of history’s most consequential atrocities. That allows room for ignorance, denial, and the normalization of prejudice. We cannot leave such an essential responsibility to chance. If it is not in the curriculum, it can be said that it never happened!

As survivors pass, the obligation to bear witness falls to their children, grandchildren, educators, and communities. Our task is not simply to preserve their testimony but to ensure that the lessons remain relevant to each new generation. It is about equipping students with the knowledge to recognize where hatred leads and the courage to challenge it.

Vermont must make Holocaust education a priority by establishing a statewide requirement and ensuring that teachers have the proper training and resources to teach it responsibly. 

I left the conference encouraged by my daughter’s generation, but also mindful of what is at stake. When the last of the Holocaust survivors are gone, the world will still need witnesses. Vermont must ensure that future generations are prepared to carry the responsibility forward.


Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Categories: Commentary

1 reply »

  1. President Thomas Jefferson said he feared that the Lord’s vengeance will not be forever delayed… Best we educate our children that there are consequences for hatred and bigotry. Who better to instruct us than the history of the people called Israel?

    Does any serious scholar deny that it is this very real and historic bigotry that necessitates the existence of a Jewish State? Its very existence should be a cautionary constant reminder that man’s history is rife with the very common anti-jew trends we witness today in America and the West generally. The real danger is that we miss the message; anti-zionism is the norm in history Not The Exception.

    Will we notice and reflect the Light Unto The Nations in our opposition to hatred and bigotry? History says “Sometimes yes, sometimes not so much…”.

    “By Myself I have sworn, says the LORD, because you have done this thing, and have not withheld your son, your only son— 17 blessing I will bless you, and multiplying I will multiply your descendants as the stars of the heaven and as the sand which is on the seashore; and your descendants shall possess the gate of their enemies. 18 In your seed all the nations of the earth shall be blessed, because you have obeyed My voice.”

    Genesis 18:16-1

All topics and opinions welcome! No mocking or personal criticism of other commenters. No profanity, explicitly racist or sexist language allowed. Real, full names are now required. All comments without real full names will be unapproved or trashed.