Commentary

St. Marthe: ‘All blacks should vote Democrat’ undermines diversity

By Rohan St Marthe

The nerve of some people, assuming that just because I am black, I must automatically support the Democratic party. This assumption is not only insulting, but it also diminishes the complexity of individual beliefs and values within the black community.

Rohan St. Marthe

It is often argued that having the first black president in the United States should be a milestone for the black community. However, I find it difficult to fully support this belief. While it is true that the election of Barack Obama was a historic moment, it does not necessarily mean that all black individuals should align themselves with his political ideology.

Furthermore, the notion that black people are obligated to vote for the Democratic party is not only disrespectful, but it also undermines the diversity of thought within the black community. Each person has their own unique set of values, principles, and political views, and it is unfair to assume that all black individuals should conform to a singular political stance.

In addition, the Democratic party’s prioritization of the gay community over their own constituents is a legitimate concern. It is disheartening to see that the needs and concerns of the black community are disregarded in favor of other groups. This highlights the need for a more inclusive and holistic approach to politics, one that addresses the concerns of all communities, regardless of race, gender, or sexual orientation.

Moreover, the Democrats’ stance on issues such as abortion further complicates the assumption that all black individuals should support the party. The narrative of encouraging minorities to abort their babies while simultaneously supporting migrants bringing their babies across the border is contradictory and perplexing.

As a member of the black community, I refuse to be used as a political football. I will no longer allow my identity to be exploited for the benefit of any political party. The time has come for individuals who look like me to assert their independence and demand that their voices be heard and respected.

The assumption that all black individuals should support the Democratic party is unjust and disrespectful. It is crucial to recognize the diversity of beliefs and values within the black community and to approach politics with an open mind and a willingness to engage in meaningful dialogue. It is my hope that, moving forward, the black community will be empowered to think independently and make informed decisions that are in line with their individual values and principles. 

The author is a Jericho resident and former GOP candidate for state senator. 


Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Categories: Commentary

15 replies »

  1. Well put.

    The simple fact is, racism is alive and well because the Left refuses to let it die its rightful death. It’s too useful a tool to let it go.

    I imagine the vitriol you receive as a Black conservative must be immense, especially from within the Black community. But I am encouraged in your efforts to get people of all stripes to think for themselves.

    For I confident that once they do, they will find like-minded citizens on the Right. And I welcome them,
    and I don’t care what they look like.

  2. The same binary thinking that assumes that all people of color should be democrats occurs all too often by many liberal progressives who automatically assign all manner of derogatory labels if you have any one of the many perspectives which they do not share. Of course they learned this from parroting the main stream media, as if being their echo chamber is some virtuous act, or perhaps they are victims of decades of programming which destroy critical thinking skills. I agree we are all no matter what we look like, each of us is an individual to whom a given perspectives cannot be assigned even when we hold a definitive position on for example issue A. That does not mean we each adopt the same ideological position on any other position B-Z.
    The same type of automatic conclusions similarly exist in the holocaust event. Most people assume this was just about culling the Jewish population, as this is what is endlessly discussed in regards to this event. However, we must be reminded that many Christians were also culled as were specific groups like gypsies etc.

  3. It’s funny how white liberal democrats seem to know what is best for America’s black community.

    Sounds like racism to me.

    • Yes. How many civilian Palestinians have been killed, or ‘culled’, so far by the Israeli government? Is it over 40,000 yet? I believe that Netanyahu won’t stop until hundreds of thousands more are killed, starved, and/or run out of their now sorry war-torn scraps of homeland. And, no, I don’t support any aspect of what Hamas does, or what they stand for.

  4. Mr. Marthe, it’s sad that the things you so articulately stated have to be stated at this stage in our history, but thank you for saying them.

  5. Replace the word Blacks, with Vermonter and you’ll find the true mental slaves of this country are white Vermonters. Of course we are the most isolated, geographically, economically and socially via the media. You can live in the toughest crime filled city, but not more than a bike ride, you’ll find a really prosperous business/family community. Not so easy in Vermont.

    Hopefully the minorities can lead our state out of this mess, we’ve adopted all the big city policies that have ruined the black communities and guess what?

    We’re getting the SAME results.

    We need a change in direction

  6. C’mon man if you don’t vote Commiecrat than you ain’t Black.

    MARK ROBINSON OF NORTH CAROLINA FOR VP

  7. Don’t walk too close to any Commiecrats Mr. St Marthe their heads will explode.

  8. Brian, I do not wish to hijack nor sully the dignity of Mr. St. Martha’s article by continuing the dialog with you in this space, but I would invite you to email me so that we can continue this conversation either in person or by phone.

    I am sincerely interested to hear from you in the hopes of trying to understand what is informing what seems to me to be your severely misinformed worldview and erroneous understanding of this issue. Here is my email if you would like to continue:
    martngreen@myfairpoint.net