|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Papineau and the Patriotes in Vermont, November 1837
by Timothy Page
In the last days of November 1837, a political movement in Lower Canada (now Quebec) turned into a refugee crisis, and northern Vermont was where many of the refugees landed. Louis-Joseph Papineau, the leader of the Patriotes, reached the United States on December 1, according to a Parks Canada chronology of his life. He had fled to Saint-Hyacinthe around the time of the Battle of Saint-Denis. [A note on the date: November 22 was the eve of that battle, not the end of the rebellion, but this the moment the movement began to fall apart.]


Papineau’s own crossing was a hard one. A 1951 account in French says he crossed Missisquoi Bay at night in a rowboat, nearly drowned, and came ashore near Swanton. It describes Swanton as a small town where fugitives were pouring in. He was not alone. Lucien Gagnon, a Patriote leader, settled in Swanton at the end of November, slipped back across the border to recruit about 60 men, and returned with them. Édouard-Élisée Malhiot also took refuge in Swanton, then recrossed with 70 to 80 men. They were stopped on December 6 at Moore’s Corner, just over the line in Quebec. Édouard-Étienne Rodier was wounded in the same clash and was carried back to Swanton.

The refugees did not stay in one place. According to the Quebec Anglophone Heritage Network, Patriote exiles lived in Alburg, Highgate Springs, Swanton, and St. Albans, and the same group that fought on December 6 had set out from Swanton with two cannons. For ordinary Vermonters near the border, the rebellion was suddenly next door. In a VTDigger history by Mark Bushnell, a crowd in St. Albans met on December 11 and asked the governor for weapons from the state arsenal. They feared British troops would cross the border, as they had in the Revolution and the War of 1812.

The governor, Silas Jenison, said no. Two days later he called out the militia to protect the frontier. He also wanted to avoid any sign that Vermont was helping the rebels, because the federal government did not want another war with Britain. Many Vermonters did not share that caution. Bushnell notes that nearly a dozen Vermont towns held rallies for the rebels. The Quebec Anglophone Heritage Network adds that meetings of support were held in December 1837 and January 1838, and that weapons and money probably followed.
The refugees also used Vermont as a place to organise and to write. Bushnell reports that Patriotes started an English-language newspaper in Swanton and a French-language one in Burlington. The University of Vermont’s research guide on the rebellion lists the Franklin Messenger of St. Albans, where it says refugees were very active, and the North American, published by exiles in Swanton from 1839 to 1841.

The movement’s biggest argument happened in Vermont, too. On January 1 and 2, 1838, Canadian exiles met in Middlebury. A scholarly article on the meeting describes a split between Papineau, who was cautious, and radicals who wanted to take up arms again. The Dictionary of Canadian Biography entry for Cyrille-Hector-Octave Côté says that at meetings in Middlebury and Swanton, Côté and Robert Nelson pushed Papineau aside and planned a new invasion. Papineau left the United States for France on February 8, 1839, the Parks Canada chronology says.
The invasion attempts failed, but Vermont courts and juries were kind to the rebels. Bushnell writes that after a failed attack launched from Alburg, American authorities charged Côté and Robert Nelson with breaking neutrality laws. A court in Windsor, Vermont, acquitted both men in May 1838, and a banquet in their honour followed in Montpelier. Over the next few years most rebels laid down their arms and went home, and the border grew quiet again.
Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Categories: History












Recent Comments