politics

Political left in Vermont doesn’t support Israel’s war against Hamas

Rallyers Saturday on the State House lawn (Bielawski photo)

By Guy Page

Recent events in Vermont and Washington show that many Vermont Progressives, socialists and others on the political left do not support the State of Israel in its struggle against the October 7 Hamas invasion. 

  1. In Montpelier last Saturday, about 250 people gathered on the State House lawn to chant (among other slogans) ‘from the River to the Sea, Palestine will be free.’ With a very few exceptions, the rallyers were young white people, not ethnic Palestinians or otherwise people of color. Most of the speakers used language clearly appealing to the political left.
  1. U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vermont), who is Jewish and a self-described socialist, opposes a pending foreign aid package because it funds Israeli military response to the Oct. 7 attack by Hamas. “I do not think we should be appropriating $10.1 billion for the right-wing, extremist Netanyahu government to continue its current military strategy. What the Netanyahu government is doing is immoral, it is in violation of international law, and the United States should not be complicit in those actions,” Sanders said in a Dec. 5 statement. (He also excoriated Hamas and said he supports defensive military spending for Israel.)
  1. Rep. Becca Balint (D-Vermont), who is Jewish and is a member of the Progressive caucus of the U.S. House, declined to support a Congressional resolution ‘strongly condemning and denouncing the drastic rise of antisemitism in the United States and around the world.’ Instead she voted ‘present,’ claiming that the “resolution makes a dangerous, unequivocal assertion that anti-Zionism is always antisemitism.”

The House roll call vote was 311 yes, 14 voting no, and 92 voting present. Republicans voted 216 yes, 1 no. Democrats voted 95-13, and all 92 ‘present votes. The No votes included longtime members of the Progressive ‘Squad’ – Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Rashida Tlaib, and Ilhan Omar. 

Balint explained her vote in a press release yesterday: “I’m deeply concerned by the rise in antisemitism in recent months – it poses a clear and present threat to Jewish communities in Vermont and around the world. My voting record stands clearly against antisemitism and any form of hate and will continue to. But today’s resolution makes a dangerous, unequivocal assertion that anti-Zionism is always antisemitism. This is another case of the majority using the real fears of many Jewish Americans to sow political divisions. As a long-standing critic of the extremist Netanyahu government, statements that paint legitimate criticisms of Israel as antisemitic are not only dangerous but undemocratic. We must lead with our values, rather than stoking hate and fear. I’m proud to consistently and firmly stand up against antisemitism and bigotry.”

The following is the entire text of the resolution, H.R. 697:

Resolution strongly condemning and denouncing the drastic rise of antisemitism in the United States and around the world.

Whereas acts of hate, intimidation, discrimination, and violence based on ethnicity or religion have no place in our country nor in the global community;

Whereas the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s working definition of antisemitism is widely accepted and serves as a critical tool to help individuals comprehend and identify the various manifestations of antisemitism;

Whereas, since the massacre of innocent Israelis by Hamas, an Iran-backed terrorist organization, on October 7, 2023, antisemitic incidents of harassment, vandalism, and assault in the United States have spiked 388 percent over the same period last year, according to reports from the Anti-Defamation League’s (ADL) Center on Extremism;

Whereas drastic increases in antisemitic activity has also been seen in Jewish communities around the world since the October 7, 2023, Hamas attacks;

Whereas the slogan “From the River to the Sea”, which is a rallying cry for the eradication of the State of Israel and the Jewish people, has been used by anti-Israel protesters in the United States and globally;

Whereas, on October 8, 2023, a car with individuals holding Palestinian flags appeared to intentionally swerve out of its lane, nearly hitting a visibly Jewish family in Clifton, New Jersey;

Whereas, on October 15, 2023, an individual in New York, New York, punched a Jewish woman in the face at Grand Central Terminal solely because she was Jewish;

Whereas, on October 28, 2023, a Jewish man in Sydney, Australia, was severely injured by 3 anti-Israel rioters, in which he was punched in the head at least 12 times, suffered a concussion, 2 black eyes, and 4 spinal fractures;

Whereas, on November 3, 2023, a Jewish woman’s store in New York City was attacked by a mob of anti-Israel protesters all because she hung posters of Israeli hostages in the store window;

Whereas, on November 3, 2023, 4 masked men walked into a restaurant in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and proceeded to tear down an Israeli flag and yelled “Free Palestine”;

Whereas, on November 4, 2023, an Arizona man was arrested by Federal authorities for threatening to execute a local Rabbi and “every other JEW I can find tonight at midnight of your Sabbath”;

Whereas, on November 4, 2023, during an anti-Israel protest in Washington, DC, rioters shouted their support for Hamas massacre on October 7, 2023, and other acts of terror targeting Israel, called for the end of the State of Israel, and spewed hateful and vile language amplifying antisemitic themes;

Whereas, during that same protest in Washington, DC, rioters stormed and tried to scale the White House fence, vandalized property by staining blood-red handprints onto the side of the White House pillars, and spray painted “Death to Israel” and “Glory to our Martyrs” on buildings in DC;

Whereas, on November 6, 2023, Paul Kessler, a 69-year-old Jewish man, tragically died due to injuries sustained when an anti-Israel protester struck him in the head with a megaphone in Los Angeles, California;

Whereas, on November 11, 2023, as part of a massive anti-Israel protest, rioters set off smokebombs in front of a synagogue in London, England;

Whereas, on November 12, 2023, police found several headstones at the Chesed Shel Emeth Cemetery, a Jewish cemetery in Brooklyn, Ohio, were desecrated with swastikas;

Whereas, on November 13, 2023, a mezuzah was torn off the doorpost of a Jewish person’s apartment and a knife was stuck into the wood in its place in Milan, Italy;

Whereas, on November 13, 2023, the evening before the March for Israel in Washington, DC, anti-Israel rioters vandalized a Jewish medical tent by spray painting “Free Gaza”, “Palestine Will Be Free”, and “Gaza Will Win”; and

Whereas, on November 15, 2023, anti-Israel protesters illegally blocked and violently attacked the Democratic National Committee headquarters, endangering the lives of individuals inside, including Members of Congress, and injuring 6 Capitol Police Officers; Now, therefore, be it

Resolved, That the House of Representatives—

(1) strongly condemns and denounces all instances of antisemitism occurring in the United States and globally;

(2) reaffirms and reiterates its strong support for the Jewish community at home and abroad;

(3) calls on elected officials and world leaders to condemn and fight all forms of domestic and global antisemitism;

(4) clearly and firmly states that anti-Zionism is antisemitism; and

(5) rejects all forms of terror, hate, discrimination, and harassment of members of the Jewish community.


Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Categories: politics

51 replies »

  1. -Where is congress while the feds are prosecuting parents for speaking up against the school district for peddling pornography to children? Where is the resolution?

    -Where was congress when people were losing their jobs because they wouldn’t take an experimental jab? Where was the resolution then?

    -Where is congress now when our borders are flooded with drugs, drug dealers, human smugglers, and random terrorists? Where is the resolution?

    -Where is congress when our people are being held in prison without a fair trial (J6)?
    Where is the resolution?

    -Where is congress when the 3 letter agency’s lied to and suppressed free speech of the American people to rig an election? (Mueller / Twitter Files / etc) Where is the resolution?

    – Where is congress when a blatent Gun Registry is created by the ATF and our 2nd amendment rights are abused? Where is the resolution?

    -Where is congress when the DOJ is directly targeting Christian individuals as terrorists? Where is the resolution?

    Also what is the status of the Hunter Biden Laptop? Anthony Weiner’s laptop? Prosecution of the Mueller investigation? How about Ukraine? Digital Dollar? Inflation? National Debt? Sudden unexplained rise in nationwide Deaths, Cancer, Blood diseases? Birth rate drops? FTX and Sam Bankman Freid? Chinese Biolabs on US soil? Food Costs? mRNA manipulation of food? Oil Reserves? FDA and CDC collusion? Pfizer manipulation of clinical trials?

    Never mind I forgot. Anti-Semitism.

    • Brian, I hope you are asking rhetorical questions, but just in case here are the answers:
      THEY LET IT HAPPEN, plain and simple
      THEY WANT IT TO HAPPEN
      THEY DO NOT CARE ABOUT YOU OR WHAT YOU THINK
      BE AFRAID because it is not going to change or stop unless We The People actually do the things we need to do to stop this and it ain’t voting.

    • Whether or not these issues have been neglected, there is a major problem emerging here and it needs to be adressed.

    • You’re not wrong so address it at its source. The source is the state of Israel, not the jewish people or the people who are against the Jewish people.

      Unless you’re saying that the nation state and religion act as one, and then in that case it’s not a democracy at all and is no different than Muslim nations.

  2. Why would it surprise Vermonter ‘s that the political left in this state does NOT support Israel. I suppose there may be a small few who are Anti-Zionist but do not outwardly participate in anti-Semitism. HOWEVER, all Anti-Semitic’s are Anti-Zionist. Balint highlights her real character as she thinks she can split hairs between the two, while by blood is connected to the Jewish people. Which is also true for Bernie Sanders. Both seem to snob their nose at the Jews, of which they are. It is almost an oxymoron, or maybe just moronic. Interestingly enough, as their far left politics as a Socialist mimics the Nazi party in so many ways. {I am not referring to my moderate democratic friends}. Remember, Hitler was part of the Socialist Party. Austrian born Hitler also was part Jewish. (Very Interesting)

    • While “all Anti-Semitic’s are Anti-Zionist…” NOT all Anti-Zionists are Anti-Semitic. And not all Conservatives support ongoing funding in support of Israeli war crimes and genocide. When over 3,000 children have died in Gaza it’s time for anyone with a moral compass to say STOP. This has nothing to do with being Jewish and everything to do with being human.

    • Stephen

      If you want a ceasefire you are actually saying you want Hamas to continue to control Gaza and to repeat the Oct 7 massacre at the even larger scale they have promised. You are saying you don’t care about the deliberate torture and murder of Israeli children but only about Gazan children. And if it weren’t for Hamas deliberately using Gazans as shields, far fewer would be harmed in the war.,

    • Yet no one is out raged by the children dying in Yemen or any part of Africa. Hamas is the political government in gaza and don’t care about Palestinians

    • that is an idiotic statement. so if Israel doesn’t continue do you think that will end the violence? or do you not care about the Hamas terrorists attacking innocent civilians while torturing and raping? the deaths will pile up until Hamas is destroyed, period. Palestinians could condemn Hamas’s actions and rebel against its leadership but they choose not to which means they are complicit.

    • Hitler’s lineage is that respect is unproven. That being said a conscientious examination of the situation in the Mideast reveals Iran, Russia, and a relentless violence on the Part of Hamas, PLO, PFLP, etc. These groups have actually destabilized the entire region.

  3. scam demic covid 19 kill shots population control heart attacks blood clots face masks zombies mindless fools vermont is number one thank you

    • Real raw news is quite ficticious. Even if I don’t necessarily disagree with your posts that source is very false.

  4. A cease fire is a victory for Hamas. If you don’t understand that, you haven’t followed the last 15 years of history in Gaza.

    So, who wants Hamas to be the victor?

  5. Why am I not surprised? These demonstrations are a strong indicator that our educational system has failed to teach history to these young people.

    I wouldn’t expect “The Origins of Totalitarianism” by Hannah Arendt, written after WWII, to be required reading for high school students, but would expect it to have been read by their teachers, or at the very least their history teachers.
    Arendt wrote in Chapter 3: “In the United States, social antisemitism may one day become the very dangerous nucleus for a political movement.” Seems prophetic.

    Even without delving deep into the history or the history of antisemitism, our children should graduate from high school able to think critically, with a basic understanding of our nations founding principles. It seems many are not. Instead, many graduate with a susceptibility to subtle propaganda that undermines our founding principles. Of course there are many other problems in our culture influencing this decline of understanding and discernment. It’s discouraging because it means the propagandists have lots of entry points and have been very successful.

  6. “Political left in Vermont doesn’t support Israel’s war against Hamas”
    The political left is against the U.S.having a secure border, and strong immigration requirements. The political left is against energy independence. The political left is against freedom of speech. (unless it is to their advantage) The political left is against the right of the people to adequately defend itself against all threats be they foreign domestic, or personal, unless it is directed against them of course. The political left is against parents having the last say as to how their children are educated, and/or politically indoctrinated . The political left has proven that they are inept, (possibly intentionally?) or weak, when national security is in question . (allowing the Chinese spy balloon, and industrial, and military spying, allowing them to buy farm land) The political left has proven over, and over again that hypocrisy is their playground . In the end I guess that what I would say is that there is very little in the way of outrageously bad, inept, or politically dirty behavior from the left that would surprise me . The end justifies any and all means to keep them in power . Adam Shiff, Jerry Nadler, Jamie Raskin, Nancy Pelosi, the Chinese lover, Eric Swalwell, Joe Biden, and any of his puppet masters, “The Squad”, our very own millionaire socialist from Brooklyn N.Y. Boinie Sanders, and yes, Becca Balint . There is nothing new, or surprising in Becca Balint’s self serving stance against a strong, secure Israel, she is going to go where she believes the votes are.

    • Balint goes where she believes the votes are? Nah. Balint goes where she is TOLD to go! Remember she was/is bought and paid for to the tune of just short of a million dollars. She will be very rich shortly.

  7. Why would this surprise anyone, the leftists will jump on any bandwagon that will contradict any common sense or facts ……….and most of these clowns couldn’t find Palestine on a map if their life depended on it.

    If they support Palestine, maybe they need to board the next plane and help out, Nah, they just want their five minutes of fame, look at us we care…….. BS.

  8. It’s sadly not at all surprising. VT leftists have been brainwashed by many years of leftist ideology. Ironically by siding with Hamas, they are actually siding with a group that would consider them useful tools and then kill them due to their intersectionality and adoption of the LBGTQ agenda among others. It’s not surprising that a bunch of young white people are supporting Hamas; it’s the cool thing to do now and they want to fit in with their peers. It makes for a great TikTok video and Instagram posts. As for Balint and Sanders, they are typical JINOS. Both only drag out their Jewish roots if it will help them politically. Neither are observant Jews and don’t live as Jews. I think they believe that by harming Israel they will score points with their base; they probably will. All manner of leftists lived in many of the kibbutzim attacked by Hamas and were at the music festival. In the end,as far as Hamas was concerned they were all just Jews.

  9. True but not just in Vermont. The political left nationwide seems to be anti-Israel and maybe beyond that antisemitic. Maybe it’s time for Jewish people to stop voting for a political party that hates them.

  10. If it was conservatives protesting for hamas the feds would lock them up. Anyone who supports Hamas/ Palestinians is an idiot.

  11. Peter Welch seems to be going even further left than Bernie on Israel and other issues. He supports a ceasefire (which Bernie has not) and even more ridiculously, co-sponsored a bill with Squad member Ayanna Pressley to allow all felons to vote, even those who are currently in jail. That guy needs some calls to his office.

    • And when you put a call into Welch’s office regarding felons voting (like they already can in Vermont) agree with him that felons should have their voting rights restored as well as their Second Amendment Rights…and see if can handle the logic.

  12. but balint, and Sanders are o.k. with the billions and billions 600 last count going to the oligarchs in the ukraine

  13. did you notice the current banking scandal never mind you have other things on your mind coverups do not last forever like 911

  14. i see slick willy sorrel and his council have slapped our sheriff up here in franklin county i am glad they caught the three speeders that tel lie vision
    reported tonight they nearly killed one of my neighbors this story has not been reported

  15. So I’m wondering why obvious troll/bot comments such as the many by mday44 aren’t removed? They have nothing to do with the subject under discussion.

  16. Sanders and Blaint had family members exterminated in the Holocaust. There were far more Jewish Vermonters at the anti-genocide rally than there were protesting it with you.

    It’s very clear that this is about the apartheid and ethnic cleansing being perpetrated by a far right ethnostate. All this dishonest talk of anti-semitism is just an effort to obfuscate support for genocide. The dividing line is whether you view Palestinians as human beings or not

    • The only “genocide” being called for is by the pro-Palestinian protesters, who want to eliminate the state of Israel.

    • @ aaronflenser

      Are you out of your mind? Apartheid and ethnic cleansing? Is that why the population of Gaza has skyrocketed with something like half now under age 15? Because they’re having genocide committed against them? It’s the other way around dude. And are they human beings? It’s actually hard for me to accept that those guilty of what Hamas has done and the majority of Gazans who fully support them ARE actually human.

    • I’m not sure that you understand how population works… A low population is not a sign of prosperity, it’s a sign of being very poor. In fact the most poor countries have the highest population growth.

      https://www.prb.org/resources/population-growth-concentrated-among-the-poorest-communities/

      Apartheid meaning: “a policy or system of segregation or discrimination on grounds of race” – One could argue that since the Jewish people are Jewish based upon their mother’s lineage that it’s racial.

      Ethnic cleansing meaning: “the mass expulsion or killing of members of an unwanted ethnic or religious group in a society” – since it doesn’t only mean killing and instead can mean expulsion like forcing those with a certain belief system into a certain area technically it fits.

      “All this dishonest talk of anti-semitism is just an effort to obfuscate support for genocide”

      We shouldn’t be talking about anti-semitism at all, it’s the state of Israel that is doing this not the religion unless you think that they are one and the same and in that case are not the democracy as claimed and not our friend in the region as it’s often stated due to being the only democracy in the middle east.

      As for the genocide part I unfortunately agree. They are not targeting just Hamas, they are targeting hospitals and cutting off all aid and rescue. They funded Hamas initially and continue to this day. They are playing both sides of the war and fooling you into supporting them. That’s not to say I support Hamas, that would be foolish as well they hate Western civilization as well. What I do support are the people caught in the middle of all of this.

      Lastly they are using AI to target and execute strikes against human beings, something that even our military has frowned on. Scary stuff.

    • @ aaronflenser

      Oh yes, and re Sanders and Balint having family members who were Holocaust victims? So what? So does Soros and he is probably the evilest Jew on the planet. And as for “Jewish Vermonters “ protesting on the same side as Hamas? No big surprise there. Many aren’t actually Jewish by Jewish law. And the rest have leftism as a religion; they wouldn’t recognize true Torah Judaism if they tripped over it. They long ceased actually being Jews; are only interested in their “progressive” values. I hope they get to meet up with some Hamas terrorists who will demonstrate to them just what they think of leftist Jews.

  17. Gaza has been an open air prison for almost 20 years …. Ruled by the iron fist of Israel …. Everything is controlled except for the false flag event of Oct 7 ….. stop giving Israel 10 million a day plus free state of the art weapons ….. it’s a genocide …. It’s a WAR in narrative only ….. Israel strikes at will with impunity …. 16000 dead and counting……

    • Larry

      If Gaza has been “an open air prison for almost 20 years”, take that up with its rulers, Hamas. Sad that you are so ignorant of this and just know the garbage you read online. Israel hasn’t been running it since 2005. I’m so sick of ignorant people who write garbage about what they don’t know or understand.

  18. Hamas, and everyone of their supporters must be eliminated before they can create more terror, murder and mayhem. It is totally illogic and dangerous to pursue any other course. Stamp them out before they spread.

  19. Would the Vermont political left care to comment on the number of dead or missing Ukrainians? Word has it their male population is decimated and now going door to door pulling out any breathing human of any age to fight. Pentagon threatening to send American citizens into the fray if we don’t send more money. Distract, deceive and destroy – no matter what front or what cause happens to fill the till.