Exec order gives State more ‘fair and impartial policing’ power

In response to aftermath of Floyd killing, Scott hands Department of Public Service bigger role in hiring, training, oversight of all Vermont police

By Guy Page

September 9, 2020 – Gov. Phil Scott’s “fair and impartial policing” executive order gives the Vermont Department of Public Safety sweeping new powers in the hiring, training and oversight of local and state police agencies. 

“Just two months ago, this country watched the tragic death of George Floyd, and while Vermont has been committed to fair and impartial policing for some time, we must acknowledge work remains to be done,” the August 20 order states. 

The order incorporates Department of Public Safety (DPS) Commissioner Michael Schirling’s January 14 “outline for modernizing policing and public safety,” for centralization of all State of Vermont law enforcement agencies (but not municipal police) under DPS. The order also builds on the administration’s June 10-point plan for fair and impartial policing.

At his Tuesday, Sept. 8 press conference, Gov. said this executive order does not use or need any special State of Emergency powers. “Racism is real” and Vermonters must work together to eliminate it, he said. His order requires:

By Oct. 1, the State of Vermont must develop and begin to implement new hiring and promotion systems of police and police executives in  “all law enforcement agencies statewide.” Developed by DPS Commissioner Michael Schirling and “community representatives and other interested parties,” these systems will help law enforcement agencies “retain and promote officers who reflect the values and diversity of the communities they serve.” 

By Dec. 1, Schirling shall “in consultation with the Commissioner of Human Resources and the Executive Director of Racial Equity, develop additional initiatives to reach out to a more diverse hiring pool.”

Schirling prioritize adoption of a statewide police dispatch and data computer system, standardized and mandatory for all agencies, to make use of force, traffic stops, arrests, mental health and other data “more swiftly and fully available to communities.”

Schirling, with Executive Director of Racial Equity Xusanna Davis and other stakeholders, develop a statewide model policy on body worn cameras for all law enforcement agencies and officers for use statewide. 

Schirling, with Executive Director of Racial Equity Xusanna Davis and other stakeholders, will develop a statewide model policy on police use of force, including when and how military equipment may be used. This policy would ban “invasive surveillance technologies, advanced autonomous weaponry, facial recognition software or predictive policing technologies….failure to adopt the statewide model use of force policy shall result in limitations on state funding and access to training for the agency.” 

By Dec. 1, report to the governor a plan to “develop and use updated, statewide training, schedules and methods.”

By Oct. 1, Schirling, Davis and others “shall recommend to the Governor a statewide model policy for investigating allegations of improper conduct. This process should consider different models used outside of Vermont, including those involving civilian investigators or investigators from other agencies. 

In addition to these executive acts, the order outlines a 2021 legislative platform for more detailed reform on police hiring, training, oversight, and review of misconduct and use of force allegations. While not ordering removal of police from schools or stripping cops of their current legal immunity from lawsuits, the executive order does call for further discussion of these two hot-button issues by local governments and the Legislature. 

VT Watercooler Comment of the Day:

ZUCKERMAN WOULD HAVE ENFORCED MASK BAN SOONER: “Zuckerman sold his soul to Big Pharma. It’s pretty sad.”

Comment on VTWatercooler news by going to

  1. Re: “Not sure the VTGOP will do anything, they won’t even complain or unite together to bring about change, why?”…

  2. An even more important question, did ANY officials make a stance against it? See, there’s the real problem.

  3. Great article. Not sure the VTGOP will do anything, they won’t even complain or unite together to bring about change,…

  4. 9-22-23 Madison, WI – Sen. Stroebel (R-Saukville) and Rep. Bodden (R-Stockbridge) introduced legislation today to have Wisconsin join 10 out…

Recent News

Categories: Crime

Leave a Reply