Burlington rabbi: “I stand with the people of Palestine, but against Hamas”

by Aaron Warner

Rabbi Jan Salzman came to Vermont in 1978 fresh out of college.  Prior to that she grew up in Skokie, Illinois,  made famous for its Neo-Nazi marches that took place when she was a child.  Skokie, at the time, had the largest Jewish population of Holocaust survivors in America outside of New York City, precisely the reason it was targeted by the Neo-Nazi’s. 

Among her neighbors were “Anne Frank types” who had been protected by righteous Christians years earlier while in Nazi Germany.  Rabbi Jan recalls hearing of the horrors endured by her neighbors and a father  who was a medic in the US Army, among the first to enter concentration camps at the conclusion of the war.  He was also shipped to Hiroshima shortly after it was devastated by American nuclear bombs.  

This past week Rabbi Jan, who leads her Burlington congregation Ruach haMaqom,  participated in the Burlington call for solidarity with the people of Israel.  Burlington is Vermont’s most ethnically diverse and multicultural city, home to the majority of Vermont’s synagogues and the primary Islamic worship center.  She spoke fondly of this fact as we discussed the terrible ordeal facing both groups of people in the latest iteration of Israeli-Palestinian conflict.  

Rabbi Jan’s unique perspective is colored by her visits to Israel where her sisters still resides in the coastal city of Haifa.  Her sister is one of many pacifists working with the Arabs in Israel to foster peace.  She tells me Israel is home to the largest number of peace groups in the world per capita, no doubt wondering what it will take to pacify the current tension. 

Rabbi Jan Salzman

When asked to explain her thoughts on the situation she makes it clear she does not view the problem as one of religious differences.  “Islam is not the problem.  Hamas is the problem.  Terrorism is the problem.”  

Hamas grew out of the Israeli withdrawal from Gaza in the early 2000’s.  Campaigning on a promise to improve the rising crime and perceived  “immorality” among the population in Gaza City,  the seven founding families of Hamas would gain political power by winning popular elections in 2004.  Though they would make good on some of their fundamentalist promises they would also turn their attention to waging military Jihad on the Jews in Israel, their annihilation being part of their  creed as well as as occupiers of Palestinian land.  

A series of terror attacks since the 2000’s would cause the Israeli government to turn Gaza into what Rabbi Jan likens to the “world’s largest open air prison”, a meme that is a talking point repeatedly mentioned by critics of the situation.  

“Gaza is not an apartheid state.  People don’t know the difference.  In apartheid South Africa the black Africans were not only forced to live in separate areas, they couldn’t get employment, or access to quality healthcare, or hold political offices.  Palestinians do work in Israel, and there are a lot of economic and social interactions with the citizens of Gaza. Yes, there are barriers, but there is a lot of interaction that happens ‘under the radar’.”

Israeli politics is another source of what she considers problematic.  Israel’s current Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is a member of the right wing,  supported by orthodox Jews who take a hard line position on how to deal with the Palestinian problem and Hamas.  Prior to the attacks Netanyahu was working to create changes in Israel’s judiciary that looked to consolidate power among conservatives.  Rabbi Salzman points out there were massive protests throughout Israel disputing this move.  The Hamas attacks occurred as Jewsish Israelis were observing a celebration known as Simkhat Torah,  when the reading of the scroll has ended and the Torah is rerolled to begin the yearly cycle once more.  The attacks focused on a Nature music festival taking place in the desert.  Hamas militants poured over the border for a surprise attack that would see over 1,000 Jews slaughtered and many more wounded, kidnapped and terrorized.  

Citing war crimes and human rights violations by Hamas, Rabbi Jan focuses her desire on the freedom of the Palestinian people by the dismantling of Hamas. 

“The people of Palestine overwhelmingly don’t support Hamas.  They are captive.  If they speak out they can be killed” she laments as she tries to describe a situation layered with political, territorial and religious entanglements.  She told me of daily life shared by Arabs, Christians, Druze, Israelis, and who work among and with each other, and emphasized that Israel is  the only democracy in the Arab world.  She is careful to remind me “Islam is not the problem, it’s terrorism” stating the vast majority of the Muslim world follow the compassionate teachings of their tradition. 

Nevertheless Hamas remains in power in Gaza and their charter calls for the eradication of the Jews often serenaded as “from the river to the sea let Palestine be free” which implies no more Jews nor Israel.  

As for America’s response Rabbi Jan believes they should support Israel as an ally, however she is deeply concerned with America’s role in arming the Israeli army and people “wanting to make money off war”.  American weapons manufacturers like General Dynamics, Lockheed Martin and McDonnell Douglas will see billions in profits this year.  As will cybersecurity firms such as Fortinet. Many have recently expressed concern regarding American politicians making investment moves, some even days before the attack, with Republican lawmakers preferring defense or energy contractors and Democrats found investing in cybersecurity.  Rabbi Salzman prefers America’s leaders focus on taking out terrorists rather than full scale war. 

The dialectic of opposition, often seen in American politics, is the same narrative that Hamas and others use to perpetuate these ideological conflicts against both the Jews and the west.  In the wrong hands a simple difference of views can be used to justify acts of terrorism, which is why Rabbi Salzman sees any hope of resolution as changing the dialectic from oppositional to reconcilable. 

When asked what she’d like to say to Vermont’s Muslim community she makes it clear.  “I stand with the people of Palestine but against Hamas.  My new saying is ‘Free Palestine. From Hamas’.”  Our conversation turned briefly to the Jewish practice of praying three times daily called the Amidah.  Among the nineteen prayers of the Amidah is a different dialectic – to end the violence perpetrated by the enemies of the Jews through the destruction of their arrogance.  

“Arrogance is the opposite of humility.  From humility comes gratitude and with gratitude we can begin to see each other differently and start the process of reconciliation.”  

The author is a fitness expert living in Hartford.

About Vermont Daily Chronicle: every weekday, we publish 10 Vermont-related news and commentary articles. Subscriptions to Vermont Daily Chronicle are free. Subscribing takes less than one minute: click here to subscribe and receive the daily edition in your email. The Vermont Daily Chronicle is supported almost exclusively by Contributing Readers who appreciate our unique place in the Vermont news media and generously give $108/year (some give more, some less) via PayPal or by writing a check to Vermont Daily Chronicle, P.O. Box 1547, Montpelier Vermont, 05641.

Categories: Religion

6 replies »

  1. She is entitled to her opinion. She’s obviously a leftist who, just like many who were brutally murdered by Hamas in Israel, really believed that Palestinians want peace; they don’t. Gazans elected Hamas. They celebrate the murder of Jews with sweets. And the Moslem religion calls for Christians and Jews to be eliminated; how is that not a problem?

  2. Interesting & Thoughful woman and I appreciate her nuanced “positions”. But as a Rabbi she would know the truth is that Islam is a cult of death and Mohammed a false prophet, at best it is an evil distraction that keeps all its proponents from the One True God, Jehovah Rafa, (healer of all things). Jesus is the only one who died and then conquered all sin and recaptured the keys to death so that we may forever live in communion with God.

    By devoting oneself to Islam, the enemy blocks every Muslim from the saving Grace of Jesus by Faith in His death and Resurrection. So even spewing “Ecumenical” partnership with Islam and saying ““Islam is not the problem. Hamas is the problem. Terrorism is the problem.”, Salzman is doing the work of Islam keeping people in the darkness…

    While Evil is still Evil, only confessions of the need for Jesus can Save against the lies and deceptions of all false and “religious” cults, even the secular religious cults of DEI and BLM and Yes, Republican and Democrat…

    Pander to these softhearted ecumenical bridge builders if you wish, but they need the Gospel news, not some lazy river of acceptance and fantasy of “human built” peace treaties and two-state “solutions”.

    “The present map of Palestine was drawn by the British mandate. The Jewish people have another map which our youth and adults should strive to fulfill: from the Nile to the Euphrates.” ~ David Ben-Gurion

    “We can forgive [the Arabs] for killing our children. We cannot forgive them for forcing us to kill their children. We will only have peace with [the Arabs] when they love their children more than they hate us…” ~ Golda Meir

    “There is no such thing as a Palestinian people… It is not as if we came and threw them out and took their country. They didn’t exist.” ~ Golda Meir

    “This country exists as the fulfillment of a promise made by God Himself. It would be ridiculous to ask it to account for its legitimacy.” ~ Golda Meir

  3. Unfortunately, the people of Palestine are not standing with you. If they were they would not have voted in Hamas as the government of Gaza.

  4. As Golda Meir rightly said, there is no such thing as Palestinians. Why do people refer to some citizens of Israel as Palestinians? It capitulates to and supports a false narrative.

  5. So we’re asked to look for a distinction between Palestinians who don’t seek the elimination of Israel and Hamas et al who do seek the elimination of Israel? Have the Palestinians been able to or have any interest in making a credible enough case for this distinction to convince the Israelis?