Commentary

Page: Repeal Road Rule, Tier 3 now – don’t delay

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

By Guy Page, Editor

So Speaker of the House Jill Krowinski is telling Vermonters concerned about Act 181, “I hear you and we will work together to get this right.”

I don’t know quite what she means. [Read full statement here.] Does she mean House leaders will repeal the odious Tier 3? And in particular the Road Rule? 

Or, does she mean they will hold hearings, nod their collective head in synchronized sympathy when Neil Ryan and Christine Stone and dozens and even hundreds of others (if given opportunity) say Act 181 will turn them into serfs? And then… do nothing but maybe delay implementation to a time more fortuitous for the Land Control crowd?

Or does it mean real reform? Repeal Tier 3? Break the deal with the devil that allows more housing in cities while virtually outlawing middle-and-working class landowners to develop family land in rural areas? 

The Senate version of Act 181 reform, now under House Environment Committee review, kicks the implementation can down the road: four years for the Road Rule, two years for Tier 3. 

This is onerous and a little scary. In maybe two and probably four years, Vermont may not have Gov. Phil Scott to say ‘whoa there podner.’ The Legislature may not have enough Republicans to back a veto, even if he’s still governor. 

In four years it could be anything-goes 2024 all over again. 

I think Krowinski and the other House leaders know this. And I think they are hoping Vermonters will believe that they’ve been listening to, and that four years really will make a positive difference.  

Governor Scott and the Republican minority have at least some swing in the State House now. For people concerned about Tier 3 and the Road Rule, now is the time to repeal.

And while we’re thinking about reform, how about Krowinski play some music for the committee chairs and leave some obstructionists standing when it stops? The chair of House Environment, Amy Sheldon, could benefit from her getting a fresh start. So think, anyway, plenty of concerned Vermonters.

The author of this opinionated commentary is executive editor of the Vermont Daily Chronicle.


Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

4 replies »

  1. Thank you Guy for sharing the (current) Act 181 situation as it is succinctly. Many people are not even aware of what is happening, and/or are downplaying it. As an owner of a small family farm (third generation), it is causing me sleepless nights. I have been fighting to retain the rights of my property for almost 20 years when I became sole owner. The worst, and most time consuming, was the Ancient Roads issue! Fortunately, I succeeded, but after over two years meetings both inside and outside.
    If I told you what Town I live in you would understand. It is pretty sad when one is embarrassed to tell people that they live where they grew up. Fill in the blanks. Fortunately, I am part of a like-minded group on FB. Finally, a large group of True Vermonters have banded together, which appears to have surprised “those people” in Montpelier!! You have pointed out the uncertainty we are dealing with right now as to if, or when, they will make decisions that will significantly affect what we can, or cannot, do with our property. There are a lot of potential issues, but one major one is how the permit costs may escalate. If they are able to accomplish all they intend to my property value will be significantly decreased.
    Okay-I will stop here. At least for now. I will be happy to answer any questions, or will attempt to.

  2. Now you people must have all been members of property owners standing together and citizens for property rights that were formed in the past few years. They tried to put an end to these land thieves.

  3. I’ve read that tier 2 affects the most Vermonters. Someone suggested making all of Vermont tier 1, I think it was Rob Roper on Vermont Viewpoint.

  4. If I was king for a day I would repeal act 181 act 250 the stupid 3 acre storm water rule and the municipal road general permit…oh but wait no kings!

All topics and opinions welcome! No mocking or personal criticism of other commenters. No profanity, explicitly racist or sexist language allowed. Real, full names are now required. All comments without real full names will be unapproved or trashed.