Crime

No drug treatment release for UVM gun thief

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

By Mike Donoghue, Vermont News First

A Burlington man, who is a familiar face in state criminal court and to area police, won’t be released from federal custody to enroll in a residential drug treatment facility while awaiting sentencing in U.S. District Court on a stolen gun charge.

Yesi Garelnabi, 34, of King Street is facing at least 11 criminal cases in Vermont Superior Court in Burlington and is due for arraignment on Jan. 13 on new state charges.  He is part of the new Accountability Court set up by Gov. Phil Scott to adjudicated ongoing repeat offenders, court records show.

Yesi Garelnabi, from 2024 Newport Dispatch news story about arrest in Brattleboro

Garelnabi is due for sentencing in U.S. District Court for a felony charge for knowingly possessing a loaded gun that he stole from a parked car at the University of Vermont on March 9, court records show.  He pleaded guilty in August and is due for sentencing in January.

But his defense lawyer said in court this week that he was hoping, ahead of sentencing, to get Garelnabi into Valley Vista, a residential treatment center in Bradford to begin his drug rehabilitation.

Garelnabi is a Burlington native and played soccer at both Johnson State and Lyndon State Colleges before graduating in 2016.  The defendant is known also as Yessi Gar-Elnabi, records show.

Burlington, South Burlington and UVM are among the police agencies in Chittenden County that have dealt with Garelnabi in recent years, mostly for illegally entering cars, stealing items, including credit cards and then trying to either use or sell the items for his drug habit, records show.

He also was under a 24-hour court-imposed court curfew at his King Street residence, but has been found in the community violating his conditions of release imposed by state judges.  

Brattleboro Police also has criminal charges for stealing out of cars in  Windham County, records show.

Chief Federal Judge Christina Reiss wasn’t buying the defense’s rehabilitation pitch this week ahead of his sentencing.

It turns out that Garelnabi also had some disciplinary reports while in prison during the summer, including one for setting a fire in a microwave in an effort to mask the smell for smoking cocaine, according to comments in court.

Assistant Federal Defender Charles N. Curlett Jr. said Garelnabi has since begun to turn the corner in recent months with no disciplinary reports.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Matt Lasher, who was filling in for the hearing, said reports indicated that Garelnabi had 3 major and 6 minors disciplinary reports while in jail leading up to the fire and possession of cocaine case.

The ATF initially arrested Garelnabi on two felony charges: knowingly possessing a stolen firearm and for willful receipt of a firearm while facing a crime punishable by more than one year in prison, records show.

Garelnabi stole the 9-mm Glock with a loaded 32-round magazine just one minute after the car was parked at the Gutterson lot at UVM about 1:10 p.m. March 9, the ATF said in court papers. 

UVM Police officers were able to capture security screenshots of the thief and shared with law enforcement.

Then-Winooski Police Officer Ahmed Sharif, who is now a Vermont State Trooper, recognized Garelnabi from going to school and playing sports with him, court records show.

Curlett said in court Garelnabi did not have a drug problem until after he got out of college. He said his client began “tugging on door handles” – the act of stealing from cars in order to get proceeds to pay for drugs.

Curlett said unfortunately for his client one car had a loaded firearm and he sold it to the wrong person – somebody of interest to the ATF.

Curlett said he hopes to ask for a time served sentence when Garelnabi is sentenced in January.  That could equate to about nine months.

State court records show his public defender was hoping for a global resolution once Garelnabi completed his residential drug rehab.

Attempts to reach Special Prosecutor Zach Weight, who is handling the frequent flyers in the Chittenden criminal court, were unsuccessful.


Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Categories: Crime

4 replies »

  1. I cant believe that a bigger case is not being made by UVM for the fact that someone had the audacity to keep a gun in their vehicle on UVM property. The subject of the theft could also on a stretch be in violation of Vermont’s “safe storage” law, by not having some level of secondary security on the firearm within the vehicle. Also, a 32-round handgun magazine is at this point prohibited in Vermont unless procured prior to the ban. Can’t we just find a way to blame the victim of the gun theft here, so that Mr. Garelnabi can continue to “turn the corner” from his past transgressions?
    Seriously, thank God for the federal courts here. This chronic offender is almost defying the laws of physics by the way he keeps spinning the Vermont District Court revolving door into perpetual motion.
    His taxpayer-paid attorney argues that “unfortunately for his client one car had a loaded firearm and he sold it to the wrong person”. How about the fact that he stole a firearm in the first place with his current level of “justice involvement” which made him a prohibited person for even possessing a gun.
    Let me reiterate a comment from above: incarceration in this case is the most appropriate drug treatment for him, as it constitutes abstinence, at least in theory, but more importantly, protects the honest public from his predations.

  2. Amen, Rich.

    “Chief Federal Judge Christina Reiss wasn’t buying the defense’s rehabilitation pitch this week ahead of his sentencing.

    It turns out that Garelnabi also had some disciplinary reports while in prison during the summer, including one for setting a fire in a microwave in an effort to mask the smell for smoking cocaine, according to comments in court.”

    Why the disciplinary report? Could he not have claimed it was a “safe microwaving site.”

    This is ridiculous on several levels. He’s not even a model citizen in jail, yet the defense expects him to be one free in society?

    Good for Judge Reiss not buying the defense’s rehabilitation pitch. We need more state’s attorneys and judges giving and enforcing the retributive justice pitch.

All topics and opinions welcome! No mocking or personal criticism of other commenters. No profanity, explicitly racist or sexist language allowed. Real, full names are now required. All comments without real full names will be unapproved or trashed.