News Analysis

House draft bill creates new tax on investment proceeds

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Would affect wealthy individuals with total income over specific thresholds

Republished from April 24 Lake Champlain Chamber advocacy newsletter

This week, the House Ways and Means Committee looked at a new draft that reflects a shift toward more of a restructuring of the state’s income tax system, instead of just a new bracket they discussed last week, as well as the creation of a new “Vermont Investment Proceeds” (VIP) tax.

  • Income Tax Overhaul: A new proposal would lower the bottom tax rate from 3.35% to 2.7% and expand the middle bracket.
  • New Top Rate: To pay for these cuts, the top marginal rate would climb to 12.7% (down from an earlier proposal of 13.3%, so we can’t say the highest bracket in the nation) for the highest earners.
  • The VIP Tax: This new 4% surtax would target investment income, such as capital gains and dividends, for individuals with total income over specific thresholds, 

What to do with the Money? The revenue generated, estimated at roughly $100 million annually, seems like an afterthought and is debatable. 

  • Option A: Use the money for broad tax relief by lowering brackets for most residents.
  • Option B: Invest in healthcare affordability, including premium caps for marketplace plans and expanded Medicare assistance.

What’s Next? No final decision has been made. The committee is currently refining how to structure the rates and exactly where to allocate the resulting revenue.  This week, the Governor noted his opposition to any tax increases when asked at his weekly press conference. 


Discover more from Vermont Daily Chronicle

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Categories: News Analysis

7 replies »

  1. Another tax Taxpelier has a one track mind. What is this tax for. a future pay raise? Sanders lives on in VT–tax the rich motto. Seems this tax will tax the affluent that moved to VT and bought property thinking VT is a nice state. WALLA. They’ll leave VT like what’s happening in CA. Welcome to the club. No need for housing, no one to occupy.. As I’ve said often, give a liberal enough rope and they will hang themselves.

    • If all they were hanging was “themselves”‘ I’d buy them the rope, but these disingenuous dirt bags want us to brake in the gallows !

  2. If I didn’t know any better, I would say this sounds like the state attempting to steal the money of those who earn it and re-appropriate it to:
    1.) Those who don’t.
    2.) The legislators behind Marxist ideas like this.
    3.) The black hole of virtue-signaling legislation inspired by utopian ideological fantasies which are devoid of common sense and respect for human dignity and liberty.

  3. Sing this to the tune of the song “Sign” by the Five Man Electrical Band .

    And the Legislator said,
    anyone getting by,
    will be taxed to death,
    So I sent a letter to my Rep.
    and I asked him to explain their debt,
    he said you sound like you need another job,
    to support yourself, and me,
    So I packed my Uhaul up,
    and I moved to Tennessee!
    Ohhh
    Tax, tax,
    everything is taxed
    emptying my wallet,
    breaking my back,
    They take my money for this and that,
    So I can’t afford to live here !

    Okay, I never claimed to be Lennon/McCartney, But I had fun!

  4. This state is like one big vacuum cleaner, sucking in all the money and blowing out hot air for the taxpayer.

  5. I don’t think the highlight will show but this is an excerpt from a 1939 law, in it you will see the IRC internal revenue code fully repealed- and in the subsequent section permission for government to continue to publish the forms as if it hadn’t Refering to the attached, look at the highlighted sections below. The first section says that the IRC is repealed and the next highlighted section says the government may continue to publish tax return forms as if it has not. See section 4 and 11 a(e) I have a copy of the full document. Feeling deceived yet ? I will be making an announcement soon, …..

    UNITED STATES
    STATUTES AT LARGE
    CONTAINING THE
    LAWS AND CONCURRENT RESOLUTIONS
    ENACTED DURING THE FIRST SESSION OF THE
    SEVENTY-SIXTH CONGRESS
    OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
    1939
    AND
    TREATIES, INTERNATIONAL AGREEMENTS OTHER
    THAN TREATIES, AND PROCLAMATIONS
    COMPILED, EDITED, INDEXED, AND PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY OF LAW
    UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE
    VOLUME 53
    PART 1
    INTERNAL REVENUE CODE
    APPROVED FEBRUARY 10, 1939
    UNITED STATES
    GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE
    WASHINGTON : 1939PREFACE
    The Internal Revenue Code, approved February 10, 1939, and
    published in this volume as Public Act No. 1 of the Seventy-sixth
    Congress, is the first Federal act of its kind since the Revised Statutes
    of the United States, approved June 22, 1874. Title XXXV of the
    Revised Statutes embraces the general and permanent statutes relat-
    ing exclusively to internal revenue, in force on December 1, 1873.
    The internal revenue title, which comprises all of the Code except
    the preliminary sections relating to its enactment, is intended to con-
    tain all the United States statutes of a general and permanent nature
    relating exclusively to internal revenue, in force on January 2, 1939;
    also such of the temporary statutes of that description as relate to
    taxes the occasion of which may arise after the enactment of the Code.
    These statutes are codified without substantive change and with only
    such change of form as is required by arrangement and consolidation.
    The title contains no provision, except for effective date, not derived
    from a law approved prior to January 3, 1939.CONTENTS
    INTERNAL REVENUE CODE: Page
    TEXT——————————————————————————– 1
    TABLE OF SUBTITLES ——————————————————– 1b
    TABLE OF CHAPTERS IN SUBTITLES ———————————— 1d
    APPENDIX:
    TABLE OF CONTENTS——————————————————— III
    PART I. REFERENCE TABLES ———————————————– V
    PART II. PROVISIONS OF THE CONSTITUTION RELATING
    TO TAXATION —————————————————– LXXXI
    PART III. MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY OR TREATY
    PROVISION———————————————————- LXXXIII
    PART IV. DIGEST OF OPINIONS CONSTRUING THE RE-
    PEAL PROVISIONS OF THE REVISED
    STATUTES———————————————————– CXCV
    INDEX————————————————————————————- CCIII
    vNOTICE
    The original of every act and joint resolution printed in this volume has the following heading:
    SEVENTY-SIXTH CONGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA;
    AT THE FIRST SESSION
    Begun and held at the City of Washington on Tuesday, the third
    day of January, one thousand nine hundred and thirty-nine
    All bills and joint resolutions presented to the President of the United States bear the
    signatures of the Speaker (or of the Speaker pro tempore) of the House of Representatives
    and of the Vice President of the United States and President of the Senate (or of the
    President of the Senate pro tempore); those signatures accordingly appear on the originals of
    all acts and joint resolutions.
    The signature of the President of the United States appears on the originals of all
    approved acts and joint resolutions.
    The original of every act and joint resolution has endorsed thereon a certificate of
    origin, signed, as the case may be, by the Clerk of the House of Representatives or by
    the Secretary of the Senate and reading “I certify that this Act (or Joint Resolution) orig-
    inated in the House of Representatives (or Senate).” The origin of the act contained in
    this part of the volume, as indicated by “H. R. 2762” in the headnote on page 1, was in
    the House of Representatives.
    viINTERNAL REVENUE CODEFEBRUARY 10, 1939
    [H. R. 2762]
    [PUBLIC, No. 1]
    Chapter 2
    INTERNAL REVENUE CODE
    Intended to Include All General and Permanent Laws of the United States and Parts
    of Such Laws, Relating Exclusively to Internal Revenue, in Force on January 2,
    1939, and All Internal Revenue Laws Relating to Temporary Internal Revenue
    Taxes the Occasion for Which Arises After the Effective Date of the Code
    ___________________
    FIRST SESSION OF THE SEVENTY-SIXTH CONGRESS
    OF THE
    UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
    ___________________
    AN ACT
    To consolidate and codify the internal revenue laws of the United States.
    Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
    United States of America in Congress assembled, That the laws of
    the United States hereinafter codified and set forth as a part of this
    act under the heading “Internal Revenue Title” are hereby enacted
    into law.
    SEC. 2. CITATION.—This act and the internal revenue title incor-
    porated herein shall be known as the Internal Revenue Code and
    may be cited as “I. R. C.”.
    SEC. 3. EFFECTIVE DATE.—Except as otherwise provided herein,
    this act shall take effect on the day following the date of its enact-
    ment.
    SEC. 4. REPEAL AND SAVINGS PROVISIONS.—(a) The Internal Revenue
    Title, as hereinafter set forth, is intended to include all general laws
    of the United States and parts of such laws, relating exclusively to
    internal revenue, in force on the 2d day of January 1939 (1) of a
    permanent nature and (2) of a temporary nature if embraced in
    said Internal Revenue Title. In furtherance of that purpose, all
    such laws and parts of laws codified herein, to the extent they relate
    exclusively to internal revenue, are repealed, effective, except as pro-
    vided in section 5, on the day following the date of the enactment of
    this act.
    (b) Such repeal shall not affect any act done or any right accruing
    or accrued, or any suit or proceeding had or commenced in any civil
    cause before the said repeal, but all rights and liabilities under said
    acts shall continue, and may be enforced in the same manner, as if
    said repeal had not been made; nor shall any office, position, employ-
    ment, board, or committee, be abolished by such repeal, but the same
    shall continue under the pertinent provisions of the Internal Revenue
    Title.
    (c) All offenses committed, and all penalties or forfeitures incurred
    under any statute hereby repealed, may be prosecuted and punished
    in the same manner and with the same effect as if this act had not been
    passed.
    11a CODIFICATION OF INTERNAL REVENUE LAWS
    (d) All acts of limitation, whether applicable to civil causes and
    proceedings, or to the prosecution of offenses, or for the recovery of
    penalties or forfeitures, hereby repealed shall not be affected thereby,
    but all suits, proceedings, or prosecutions, whether civil or criminal,
    for causes arising, or acts done or committed, prior to said repeal,
    may be commenced and prosecuted within the same time as if this
    act had not been passed.
    (e) The authority vested in the President of the United States, or
    in any officer or officers of the Treasury Department, by the law as it
    existed immediately prior to the enactment of this act, hereafter to
    give publicity to tax returns required under any internal revenue law
    in force immediately prior to the enactment of this act or any informa-
    tion therein contained, and to furnish copies thereof and to prescribe
    the terms and conditions upon which such publicity may be given
    or such copies furnished, and to make rules and regulations with re-
    spect to such publicity, is hereby preserved. And the provisions of
    law authorizing such publicity and prescribing the terms, conditions,
    limitations, and restrictions upon such publicity and upon the use
    of the information gained through such publicity and the provisions
    of law prescribing penalties for unlawful publicity of such returns
    and for unlawful use of such information are hereby preserved and
    continued in full force and effect.
    SEC. 5. CONTINUANCE OF EXISTING LAW.—Any provision of law
    in force on the 2d day of January 1939 corresponding to a provision
    contained in the Internal Revenue Title shall remain in force until
    the corresponding provision under such Title takes effect.

All topics and opinions welcome! No mocking or personal criticism of other commenters. No profanity, explicitly racist or sexist language allowed. Real, full names are now required. All comments without real full names will be unapproved or trashed.