By Clara Morrison, Executive Director of Right for Vermont Foundation
Governor Phil Scott has a decision to make before January 1, and Vermont families should be paying attention. A new federal program could give Vermont children access to privately funded scholarships to cover educational costs, but they can benefit only if the governor opts in, and he should.
Starting in January, anyone who pays federal taxes can donate up to $1,700 a year ($3,400 for a married couple) to a nonprofit scholarship organization and get every dollar back as a credit on their federal taxes. Those nonprofits then give scholarships directly to students for tutoring, after-school and summer programs, books, tuition and more. Families earning up to three times their area’s median income can qualify, which in Vermont includes many middle-class households.
Because donors are paid back through their federal taxes, the program doesn’t cost the state anything, and it doesn’t add to your property tax bill. If Vermont doesn’t opt in, Vermonters can still donate and claim the credit, but their money will go to students in New Hampshire, New York or one of the more than 30 other states that have joined.
The governors on both sides of us have already said yes. New Hampshire’s Republican governor, Kelly Ayotte, joined in January. New York’s Democratic governor, Kathy Hochul, joined in October after concluding the program could help “students and families without taking a single dollar from public schools or our state or local budgets.”
Most public school teachers agree. A national survey of teachers found that 72% of public school teachers support their state opting in, slightly more than private school teachers, and among NEA members, two-thirds support participation. Teachers know what an extra tutor or a summer program can mean for a student who is falling behind, and the governor should trust them.
But even if he opts in, Vermont’s path is more complicated. The state has until mid-February to send the federal government a list of approved scholarship organizations. But a state law passed last session limits which organizations can be on that list in ways federal rules don’t allow. As a result, Vermont likely can’t submit its list until the Legislature updates that law after it returns in January.
That uncertainty is no reason to wait. If Governor Scott opts in now, Vermont keeps its options open, and with cooperation from legislators, students could start receiving support next year. If he doesn’t, the door closes for 2027 no matter what happens in Montpelier, and Vermont families will watch the money go elsewhere.
With school budgets and property taxes already under strain, Vermont should be giving every child every chance to get the help they need, whatever school they attend. Joining the program costs the state nothing and keeps that chance alive. Governor Scott should opt in before January 1.

