Site icon Vermont Daily Chronicle

Fair Share Vermont and the $419 million tax question

by Dave Soulia, for FYIVT.com

MONTPELIER, Vt. — A coalition of Vermont advocacy organizations is preparing to renew its campaign for higher taxes on affluent residents when the Legislature reconvenes in January, with proposals potentially generating more than $400 million annually.

The effort follows a 2026 legislative session in which multiple tax-increase proposals failed, including a Senate amendment defeated 27–2. With Democrats and Progressives regaining legislative supermajorities in November, the proposals could receive renewed consideration.

The debate also intersects with proposals for publicly financed primary care, including a plan advanced during the gubernatorial campaign by Amanda Janoo.

Who Is Behind Fair Share?

The Fair Share for Vermont coalition lists 16 participating organizations, including the ACLU of Vermont, Planned Parenthood Vermont Action Fund, Public Assets Institute, Vermont Conservation Voters, Vermont Early Childhood Advocacy Alliance, Vermont Natural Resources Council, Vermont-NEA, Voices for Vermont’s Children, AFL-CIO, AFT Vermont, Hunger Free Vermont, Housing and Homelessness Alliance of Vermont, Rural Vermont, Rights & Democracy, Vermont Public Interest Research Group, and Vermont State Employees Association. Individual steering committee member Alex Hilliard is also listed.

Rights & Democracy explicitly supports increasing taxes on higher-income Vermonters through the coalition.

Green Mountain Democratic Socialists of America is not listed as a coalition member, but it backed H.794 and S.282 directly, calling sponsors Vyhovsky and Logan “our own.” Its 2026 candidate questionnaire asked candidates whether they supported income-tax increases above $250,000 and a separate tax on investment proceeds.

The questionnaire also asked candidates whether they supported fully implementing Act 48, Vermont’s 2011 single-payer health-care law.

What the Legislature Considered

House bill H.794, sponsored by Representatives Kate Logan, Brian Cina, and Chloe Tomlinson, proposed:

Senate bill S.282 proposed similar measures. (Track H.794 and S.282 in Bill Wrangler.)

Neither bill became law.

On May 1, Senator Tanya Vyhovsky offered comparable income and investment-tax provisions as an amendment to H.933. The Senate rejected the amendment 27–2.

The coalition continues promoting three income-tax alternatives, with estimated annual collections ranging from $114 million to $344 million. H.794 sponsor Kate Logan told the House Ways and Means Committee the largest surcharge package would raise $344 million a year and the 4% investment tax another $75 million: together, approximately $419 million annually.

What Would Taxpayers Pay?

Vermont’s existing top marginal income-tax rate is 8.75%. Under H.794, the combined additional surcharge on income above $500,000 would be eight percentage points, potentially raising the top marginal state income-tax burden to 16.75% on affected income.

For a taxpayer with $1 million in annual federal adjusted gross income, the proposed income surcharge alone would add $45,000 annually. At $2 million, the additional liability would reach $125,000.

Qualifying investment income could face another 4% tax, subject to the bill’s thresholds and calculations.

These are marginal increases, not flat taxes on all income.

According to the Vermont Joint Fiscal Office, the state’s top 1% of resident income-tax returns in 2024 comprised 3,298 filings reporting approximately $5.16 billion in adjusted gross income.

Those taxpayers paid $345.9 million in Vermont income taxes, representing approximately 29.8% of total resident income-tax collections, against 16.7% of reported adjusted gross income.

Applying H.794’s maximum income-surcharge formula to those historical returns produces approximately $297 million in additional taxes from that group alone, assuming unchanged incomes and behavior.

Their combined state income-tax payments would rise approximately 86%. This calculation excludes the separate investment tax.

Where Would the Money Go?

The coalition identifies replacing federal funding reductions and supporting additional public investments as objectives. Its revenue projections do not include a binding allocation among individual programs or direct taxpayer refunds.

H.794, however, contained a specific statement of legislative intent.

Section 9 proposed reserving income-surcharge and investment-tax proceeds for implementation of Green Mountain Care, Vermont’s previously authorized universal health-care system.

That provision expressed legislative intent rather than making an actual appropriation.

The Senate proposal did not contain the same designation.

The Shumlin Comparison

In December 2014, Governor Peter Shumlin abandoned Vermont’s planned single-payer health-care financing system.

The administration projected approximately $4.34 billion in annual program costs for 2017, requiring $2.58 billion in new state revenue.

Proposed financing included an 11.5% employer payroll tax and an income-based household payment reaching 9.5%.

Unlike today’s primary-care proposals, that system was designed to replace much of the existing private health-insurance financing structure.

The administration concluded the required taxes presented unacceptable economic risks.

The current $419 million Fair Share projection is substantially smaller, but it would not independently finance the comprehensive system envisioned in 2014.

Would Insurance Premiums Decline?

During the 2026 gubernatorial campaign, Amanda Janoo proposed publicly funded primary and preventive care financed through higher-income tax surcharges. She cited a preliminary annual program cost of approximately $320 million.

The proposal would eliminate patient charges for covered primary-care services while leaving hospitalizations, specialist services, and other medical expenses within existing financing arrangements.

Consequently, residents would generally still require health insurance.

Vermont’s Act 173, enacted in June, establishes additional primary-care payment requirements and directs agencies to study financing options. It does not establish universal publicly funded primary care or guarantee reductions in private insurance premiums.

For 2027, the Green Mountain Care Board approved individual-market premium increases of 2.2% for Blue Cross Blue Shield of Vermont and 3.9% for MVP.

Public financing could reduce insurance claims expenses for primary-care services. Whether insurers would pass through those savings, and whether household savings would exceed additional taxes, remains unquantified.

The Physician and Revenue Questions

Vermont’s 2024 physician census counted 529 physicians primarily practicing primary care, with statewide primary-care physician capacity equivalent to approximately 402 full-time positions.

Thirty-one percent of primary-care physicians were at least 60 years old.

Eliminating patient charges could increase demand for appointments. Whether Vermont has sufficient clinicians to accommodate that demand without longer waits remains uncertain. Improved preventive care could also reduce subsequent emergency visits and hospitalizations.

Financing presents another uncertainty.

The coalition’s revenue estimates are projections, not guaranteed collections. Taxpayer relocation, changes in reported income, and delayed investment gains could affect actual receipts. Vermonters relocating out of state may remain liable for taxes on Vermont-source income.

A permanent publicly funded program would require continuing revenue even if collections fell below projections.

Act 173 requires additional reports on primary-care spending and financing by January 15, 2027.

Those findings could provide legislators with further information about program costs, available capacity, insurance-premium effects, and the revenue needed to sustain expanded publicly financed care.

Exit mobile version