
By Michael Donoghue
Vermont News First
BURLINGTON — A Connecticut man, who defrauded nearly $470,000 from the Vermont state treasurer’s office, has been linked to a conspiracy that tried to steal $8.4 million across 19 states from unclaimed property accounts, according to new federal court records.
Cirt F. Lindsay, 43, of Bridgeport, Conn. was sentenced Monday in U.S. District Court in Burlington to 14 months in federal prison for conspiracy to commit mail fraud as part of the scam to defraud the Unclaimed Property Division for the Vermont State Treasurer’s Office.
Chief Federal Judge Christina Reiss imposed three years of supervised release once discharged from prison. She also ordered Lindsay to pay more than $1.97 million in restitution and issued a $467,067 forfeiture notice.
She admitted Lindsay would likely not be able to pay much back.
“The FBI estimates that Lindsay was involved in scams targeting $8.4 million in unclaimed funds in 19 states, $4.6 million of which were successful, and personally obtained more than $646,000 in the years in which he ‘cleaned’ fraud proceeds from fake bank accounts,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Dana E. Hill wrote in his sentencing memo.
Hill initially proposed a 3-year federal prison term, but Judge Reiss said that would be hard to impose when one of the main players in the multi-state fraud case received only a two-year prison sentence.
Shaka Stayman, 45, of Atlanta, Ga. was sentenced earlier this year in U.S. District Court in Alabama to 24 months in prison, followed by three years of supervised release.
The other main player, Matthew J. Crupi, whose age and hometown were not readily available in court records, was placed on probation for five years last month by a federal judge in Alabama, officials said.
Judge Reiss noted that the first defendant to come clean in criminal cases often gets the best deal from authorities.
She reminded Lindsay that even after the FBI arrested him and had considerable evidence, he continued to claim he had no idea that he was involved in a major interstate fraud.
“When confronted by law enforcement, Lindsay did what he was paid to do. He feigned ignorance and pretended that he was duped by clever con men,” wrote Hill, the prosecutor.
“It was a sustained endeavor over the course of years involving hundreds of actions taken and coordinated with others. With each next criminal choice, Lindsay obtained ever more ill-gotten gains and ‘cleaned’ these fraud proceeds for his conspirators – earning his 20 to 30 percent share of the take when he did so. Even to this day, Lindsay continues to minimize his role in this scheme,” Hill wrote.
Assistant Federal Defender H. Samuel Ansell argued for “time served” – which actually equated to no time in jail because Lindsay has been free on bail since his arrest 13 months ago.
He has two sons, 16 and 11 years-old and also needs to put his home on the market, Ansell said. Any profits would go toward the restitution order. Ansell said Lindsay, who is a restaurant manager, needs to provide notice at work.
Reiss did grant a defense request to give time to Lindsay to get his affairs and family in order. The judge ordered him to report to prison Dec. 29. She agreed to recommend a federal prison near Bridgeport, Conn.
Reiss was still concerned about his minimalization of the criminal conduct and that he did not come clean with the FBI initially.
The federal indictment in Vermont said Lindsay conspired with at least two swindlers to trick the state Treasurer’s office in Montpelier into forwarding a check for $467,067 that was intended for a former Essex Junction man then living in Florida. The man was known as “J.W.” according to court records.
Lindsay and two others had spent all but $5,300 from the Vermont case by August 2022, the indictment said.
Vermont State Treasurer Michael S. Pieciak has not offered any comments on the prosecution and has refused to return multiple phone, email and text messages over the past year concerning the case.
It is unknown what, if any, safeguards have been implemented by the treasurer’s office to try to stop other fraudsters from unlawfully obtaining state funds.
Newly filed court documents indicated that the former Essex Junction man thought he had received a bogus mailing about having money in the unclaimed property account for the state treasurer and dismissed the outreach as fraud.
Instead the crooks figured out a way to steal the $467,067 from the Vermont state treasury, records show. They provided J.W.’s real address, his real social security number, his real Florida driver’s license with other false information and a notarized signature with a fake notarization, Hill said.
They also created a business in Vermont in the name of the man, while Lindsay created a bank account near his home in Connecticut for the bogus company, Hill said.
When the Vermont Treasurer’s office issued the $467,067 check in April 2021, it flip-flopped the first and last name of the business. The conspirators adapted quickly by reincorporating a new business and obtaining a new IRS number and bank account using the name “W., J. A.” It allowed for a bank deposit on April 14, 2021 without raising questions, Hill said.
The conspirators quickly drained the account to include a $21,000 cash withdrawal by Lindsay, four mortgage payments, four car payments. Lindsay also took trips to Trinidad and Tobago, where he was born, and Atlanta, records show. His girlfriend and children also took trips, records show.
When Lindsay used more money he obtained from a fake business Connecticut to try to replenish the account, but the bank accounts were frozen, an investigation started and his conspirators stopped using Lindsay to funnel their checks into fake accounts, Hill said.
“Lindsay did not make one or two rash choices. He devoted years of effort to profiting from fraud and helping his friends perpetuate and profit from it as well. He enjoyed those profits and wanted to profit more; he did not stop until banks started freezing his accounts,” Hill said.
Lindsay got into the mail fraud conspiracy when he went to pick up Stayman, a former classmate from Berkely College who was getting out of federal prison in 2019 on a fraud conviction. It turned out that Stayman and Crupi conceived the scheme while serving time in the Federal Bureau of Prisons for separate wire fraud convictions, Ansell said.
Part of the plan was for Stayman and Crupi, as professional fraudsters, to avoid using their own names and identities on transactions to try to avoid getting caught and going back to prison, Ansell said. They needed a second-tier accomplices, like Lindsay, he said.
Stickman initially got Lindsay to co-sign for a car loan before approaching him for the scam, Ansell said.
Stayman and Crupi decided to use Lindsay to set up bank accounts and businesses so the money illegally obtained could be properly circulated, officials said.
“When states were fooled into issuing checks, Lindsay would create bank accounts in the names of those fake entities, deposit the fraudulently obtained checks, take his 20-30 percent cut of the proceeds and give access to his co-conspirators to spend the rest,” Hill said in his sentencing memorandum.
After early success in 2019, it fueled the conspiracy.
“Emboldened by the success of this scam, the conspirators ramped up their efforts over the course of 2020 to target and obtained hundreds of thousands in unclaimed state-held funds,” Hill said.
In early 2020, they targeted $80,423 in unclaimed corporate funds in Wisconsin. By May 2020 they targeted $78,843 in corporate funds held by Iowa and $600,000 held by California. By July 2020, they targeted $84,569 in unclaimed corporate funds held by Georgia. In August 2020 they targeted $321,077 in unclaimed corporate funds held by South Dakota.
By December 2020 they targeted $581,210 in unclaimed corporate funds held in Minnesota, records show. The conspirators persisted in the lucrative scheme – uncaught, undeterred, and unafraid – throughout 2021, Hill said.
In January and February 2021 the targeted $1,250,978 in South Dakota and by late summer they were seeking $219,419 in unclaimed personal funds held in Alaska. They also hit up Illinois for $1,825,016, but were not successful, so they went back to Minnesota for an individual’s unclaimed personal funds, records show.
A federal grand jury in Burlington indicted Lindsay Sept. 18, 2025 and court records were ordered sealed until he was arrested Oct. 1, 2025 in Bridgeport, Conn., the FBI said.
Lindsay initially denied the charge. He was released from court and eventually agreed to plead guilty to mail fraud, records show.
When he first tried to admit his guilt, Lindsay showed up in court Reiss noted he tested positive for THC while meeting earlier in the day with the U.S. Probation Office. THC is the main psychoactive ingredient in certain drugs, including marijuana and hashish.
Reiss said Lindsay tried to explain he had not smoked anything, but that he had been around people using illegal drugs.
The longtime judge said she did not find Lindsay’s explanation credible. Reiss stated various national studies have shown that close proximity to a drug will not cause a positive test in others.
The judge said she would not proceed with the planned change of plea because it was unknown if Lindsay was high or not for the court hearing.
Ansell, his public defender, said his client was willing to retract the earlier statement he provided to the Probation Office about being near drug users causing the positive test.
Reiss said she would schedule a new hearing date.
“Don’t come high,” Reiss warned Lindsay.
During his arraignment a year ago, Lindsay was warned by Federal Magistrate Judge Kevin Doyle to refrain from any new crimes and was specifically told that any illegal drug use, including marijuana, would be a violation of his conditions.
The Vermont Unclaimed Property Division collects uncashed pay checks, unrefunded security deposits, stocks, mutual funds, items from safe deposit boxes, retirement accounts and other lost property deposited with the state.

