Site icon Vermont Daily Chronicle

Burlington agreed on security for City Hall. What can downtown workers count on?

City Hall has guards and written rules. Downtown employers asked for night patrols and check-ins. Here’s what the record shows they got.

by Compass Vermont

In June, Burlington Mayor Emma Mulvaney-Stanak locked herself in the bathroom of Belleville Bakery to get away from a man she feared. The bakery owner asked him to leave. Once he was gone, the mayor’s assistant radioed Chocolate Thunder, the city’s private security company. Its guards walked the mayor and her lunch guest back to City Hall, according to a Vermont Superior Court decision.

Since then, Burlington has posted a guard at the stairs to the mayor’s third-floor office and put in writing what can get a visitor banned from City Hall. A year before the bakery, downtown business owners had asked the mayor for protection of their own: walking patrols, and people who would stop into shops at night to check on whoever was working. City Hall’s protection is now in writing. What downtown workers can count on is less clear.

The Man at the Bakery

The man was Aryeh “Ari” Moskowitz, a Burlington resident who runs an Instagram account criticizing the mayor. He pleaded not guilty on June 15 to stalking and aggravated disorderly conduct. His attorney, Robert Kaplan, told the court the police affidavit describes a “passionate constituent wanting to speak with an elected representative.” At a later court hearing, Moskowitz testified that at the bakery he was trying to show he “did not present a threat,” and that he left when the owner asked him to.

In October, Superior Court Judge Colin Owyang ruled that Moskowitz’s conduct after a January city meeting and at the bakery amounted to stalking under Vermont law. The judge kept a six-foot stay-away order in place. Moskowitz’s release conditions in the criminal case, set in June, bar him from coming within 300 feet of City Hall.

Chittenden County State’s Attorney Sarah George recused herself from the criminal case because Moskowitz had contacted her and she could be called as a witness. Lamoille County State’s Attorney Aliena Gerhard is prosecuting it.

What City Hall Has Now

Chocolate Thunder has guarded City Hall under a city contract since 2024. On June 29, the City Council voted unanimously to renew the contract for another year at up to $206,000. That works out to about $564 a day.

Since June, a guard at the staircase to the third floor has turned away anyone without an appointment with the mayor’s office or the Community and Economic Development Office, Seven Days reported.

On July 22, the city enacted a written policy listing what can get someone banned from the building. The policy calls a ban a “trespass.” In plain English:

The rule that has drawn the most attention bans people for 30 days for staying more than 10 minutes. The policy applies it only when someone stays in a public area without city business and intends to annoy, disrupt or obstruct city employees. Both conditions must be met. The policy names waiting out the City Clerk’s lunch break, or waiting for a scheduled meeting with staff, as acceptable reasons to stay. Staff must give a verbal warning before a ban, except for seriously harmful conduct.

What Downtown Employers Asked For

On May 9, 2025, a group of downtown business owners sent the mayor an open letter. Many of their employees, “particularly young women and students,” felt unsafe coming to work, they wrote. Street harassment, visible drug use and threatening behavior had led several staff members to quit after one or two shifts. They asked for walking patrols and trained community ambassadors who would stop into businesses at night. “Small businesses cannot serve as crisis responders,” they wrote.

What the City Has Done Downtown

Burlington has done this with a shrinking police force. The department is down to 54 officers with 19 vacancies, according to a report to the Police Commission, VTDigger reported. Counts of where the force started differ: the city’s own reports put it at 92 officers in July 2020, while Seven Days used 99 for June 2020.

The mayor says her approach is working. Violent crime is below 2024 and 2025 levels, she said in August. In October, she asked the council to pull Burlington Forward, the Democrats’ downtown public safety plan, and work with her on a joint policy instead. She said the plan calls her approach ineffective “without offering data or evidence to support this claim.”

Council President Ben Traverse said in August that the plan was meant to restore “a simple expectation that everyone in Burlington feel safe.” Not every downtown worker agrees with that approach. Six unions, including workers at Gaku Ramen, signed an Oct. 26 letter opposing Burlington Forward. They called for housing, addiction treatment and mental health care instead. “Burlington should set an example of caring for people, not punishing them,” they wrote.

What Comes Next

On Oct. 26, the council voted 9-3 to put off Burlington Forward until Dec. 7. In the meantime, the mayor, Traverse and the council’s two caucus chairs are to meet and report back. For anyone locking up a shop downtown, one test of what comes out of that meeting is whether they will know who to call at closing time.


What you need to know, so you can decide for yourself

If you’re closing a downtown business and feel unsafe:

If you have business at City Hall:

Exit mobile version