Commentary

Cairns: Advance child tax credit a landmine

by Steve Cairns

The Advance Child Tax Credit is an entitlement that needs to be repealed. However, it will do a lot of damage in the meantime:

1)    This is the first time that the US government will send cash to US taxpayers without their consent that they may have to give back when it comes to tax filing time.   All previous “refundable” credit programs such as EITC, Additional Child Tax Credit (NOT to be confused with Advance Child Tax Credit), the ACA PTC, the Recovery rebate credit have to be applied for and have never had to be returned to IRS.

2)    This is the first time that these type of entitlement payments are going to couples with up to $440,000 of income.  It is true that couples in this range have been eligible to receive a child tax credit for the last 3 tax years, but it was treated as a “payment” on the tax return and was never subject to any give back rule (except for the ACA subsidies prior to 2021).

3)    The opt-out process is complex and too late.   IRS only brought online the opt-out tool a few weeks ago and it is understandably difficult to use since you have to create a secure account on IRS.gov before you can do anything.   This in itself is dangerous to taxpayers because access to these new accounts can easily be gained by the criminals.   

I can go on.   We have reached a dangerous inflection point in the administration of the US tax code.   The transition of the old IRS to the new IRRS has made a giant leap.  Unfortunately, there will be more of these shenanigans to come.

The author operates Stowe Tax Services

Categories: Commentary

3 replies »

  1. Who is going to pay for THIS BOONDOGGLE? Those of us on Social IN security. we are already struggling. How about we DOCK the Pay and PERKS of the POLITICIANS who though of this FIASCO!!!

  2. is it possible for the author to explain this a little more. I’m just not understanding what the issue is. Thanks.

    • David, I would be happy to elaborate (and will int the future) on this for you (and everyone else). What are your questions ?

Leave a Reply