Commentary

Klar: The left’s hatred has escalated post-Trump

The work of Ryszard Legutko offers insight into leftist ideology today, and why Americans must stand and fight this insidious evil. Republished from March 4 Human Events.

ByJohn Klar

Hillary Clinton infamously declaimed “half of Trump’s supporters” as “irredeemable” and a “basket of deplorables.” Barack Obama sneered at “bitter” Americans who “cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them…” Joe Biden condemned “10-15% of Americans” as “just not good people.” This dehumanization of the other, a propaganda tool essential for war and genocide, is a central tenet of America’s New Left—an ideological departure not only from “old-school” liberalism, but from the Constitutional foundations of the nation.

“Classical” liberalism distrusted the state which it saw as a threat to individual liberties. In the 1960’s, this way of thinking evolved into a modern liberalism, which viewed government as the vehicle by which social and economic equity could be achieved. This doctrinal evolution may have been in good faith, but has bloated into a progressive politicization that increasingly controls citizens’ lives with utopian proposals. Thus, the political theory founded on individual liberty from state interference mutated into the present determination to employ the state to enforce ever-expanding moral, economic, and cultural oversight. The reparations effort, climate change, the #metoo movement: all call for government encroachment in the name of liberty (including even the elimination of subconscious racism).Report Ad

The vilification of those who do not conform to its tenets is fundamental to liberal-democratic dogma. Leftwing hatred went full-throttle following the Capitol assault. Particular care was taken to vilify all conservatives, linking them to the KKK and Nazis. One histrionic editorial published the day after declared: “The lineage between the slaveholding secessionists and the modern insurrectionists could not have been more clear: Both groups were willing to destroy the union and both used violence to deflect their own racial fantasies of power and privilege slipping away.”

Donald Trump has passed from view, but the virus of New Leftism is thriving and easy to see. And what is visible is that it is a bitter, seething contempt, far wider than any one man.

Another commentator, writer and American Unitarian pastor John Pavlovitz, claimed that former President Trump exposed other people’s hate. Pavlovitz writes that Trump gave “like-minded people license” to “unapologetically admitting who they always were but were previously fearful of declaring.” He continues: “You became the flag they could proudly wave in defiant hatred of so many. You’ve made bigotry, misogyny, and racism socially acceptable again and that has been a kind of twisted gift because it’s allowed me to really see people; not as they pretend to be on the surface—but in the very depths of their wounded, weaponized hearts.”

The left’s seething rage was never caused by Donald Trump, but he became a perfect lightning rod for it ever since he made his way down the now-infamous golden escalator in 2015. Now, with President Trump out of office, the contempt for America, the Constitution, and fellow citizens that undergirded the Obama/Clinton/Biden-esque demonizing of American conservatives is not only openly visible—it’s official policy. New Leftists, that spent the last four years insisting that “no human is illegal,” and “kindness is everything,” are now in power, and the bankruptcy of their lawn-sign ideology has become evident.

The conflation of Donald Trump, his supporters, and all conservative Americans with slaveholders and the Schutzstaffel may seem flippant, but it is intentional and extremely dangerous. These conflations are now uncritically repeated by a left who spent the last four years characterizing Donald Trump and popular conservatism as a “threat to democracy,” a threat to America, and a threat to our national security. And threats, as we all know, are meant to be exterminated.

There is a form of “pathological dualism” that pervades leftist thinking post-Trump, one that divides people into “unimpeachably good” and “irredeemably bad” categories. In their 2018 bestsellerThe Coddling of the American MindGreg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt describe how the left can revert to a politics of hate and blame with so little cognitive dissonance (italics in original):

“Identity can be mobilized in ways that emphasize an overarching common humanity while making the case that some fellow human beings are denied dignity and rights because they belong to a particular group, or it can be mobilized in ways that amplify our ancient tribalism and bind people together in shared hatred of a group that serves as the unifying common enemy.”

The left’s ideological hatred (and ideology of hatred) cannot be appeased: there is no such thing as “agree to disagree.” The evidence for this contempt for all things Constitutional and American has been mounting for some years, though many hoped it would subside once Donald Trump faded from the scene. Instead, left-wing hate is being mainstreamed and normalized by leaderscultural icons, even late-night liberal talk shows, which have started to resemble witch-burnings, so mouth-foaming is their uncorked partisan wrath against fellow Americans who voted “unacceptably.”

There is no hope that this ideological virus will fade: it must be vituperatively opposed. That’s the advice of European Parliamentarian and scholar Ryszard Legutko, who, having lived under martial law and communist rule in Poland, is one of the few voices qualified to recognize the dangers of liberal-democratic ideology. In March 2019, two years after a crowd of Middlebury College students shouted down Charles Murray, Professor Legutko made headlines when he too was silenced by unruly radicals who, in effect, proved Legutko’s chief premise: leftist ideology does not tolerate dissent.

AMERICA’S UNIQUE ROLE IN THIS GLOBAL BATTLE

It is baffling that those who say they are “inclusive,” “tolerant,” and “diversified” are the most monolithic group-thinkers ever to arise as a majority in America’s landscape. Professor Legutko explains, in detail, how this bizarre ideology arose, why it is so dangerous, and what its intentions are. His emphasis on the United States is two-fold: the encroachment of leftist ideology seems to be intensifying here, and (more importantly) the entire world depends on America to hold the fort of civilization against this toxic cult that threatens genocidal fury if the walls of our constitutional Republic are torn down. He writes, “…in America we can still see a culture war continuing unresolved for decades, although the forces of the left seem to prevail gradually over those of the right. Europe has not had such a war, and it is highly unlikely it will break out in the foreseeable future as there is no social force of any significance that could launch an offensive against the cultural monopoly of the left.”

Legutko instructs that liberal-democratic ideology is neither liberal, nor democratic. Instead, it bears persistent similarities to communist ideology, including its view of itself as a church-like savior of all humanity. This explains the flurry of vague “social justice” laws that disregard conventional Constitutional law and its protections, as well as the reckless proliferation of government-imposed “equity” programs. Instead of a free people living in communities protected by a Bill of Rights against government intrusion, Biden et al. rush to expand government rapidly into every aspect of society, including thoughteducationfamily, and the economy.

As Legutko explains, “In its essence, liberalism is unabashedly aggressive because it is determined to hunt down all nonliberal agents and ideas, which it treats as a threat to itself and humanity. The organizing principle of liberalism—as in all other philosophies aiming to change the world radically—is therefore dualism, not pluralism.”

The likeness to communism also explains the erstwhile communist whistleblowers are visible in today’s America, reporting neighbors for mask or social distancing “violations,” displaying a (constitutionally-protected) confederate flag, uttering a microaggressive comment, or “misusing” a trans-pronoun.  Legutko describes these new “warriors” (who take no actual risks, because the entire media and state establishment backs them):

“An intellectual’s sharp eye and perceptiveness will always recognize what is politically dangerous: a sentence, a metaphor, a proverb, an incorrect text on the bulletin board, a work of fiction—a seemingly little thing and yet shamelessly undermining the liberal-democratic rules. And because liberal-democracy, like communism, produced large numbers of lumpen-individuals, there is no shortage of people who ecstatically become involved in tracking disloyalty and fostering a new orthodoxy.”

Liberal-democratic ideology is utopian, seeing itself as the sole arbiter for all things “good” for humanity’s future: saving the planet, stopping hateful racism and sexism, undoing wealth disparity, ending all suffering forever. A deeper (albeit, fictional) exploration of this delusional phenomenon of crafting human utopias was undertaken by Fyodor Dostoevsky, in his prophetic novel The Possessed. Scathingly condemned by leftists of his time (according to a 1962 afterword by Marc Slonim), “[t]he indignant liberals saw in it a calumny on the Russian intelligentsia.” Dostoevsky foretold with eerie precision the subsequent dark purges in the Soviet Union. His novel reveals the narcissistic cynicism of the Revolution’s leaders: that the people are used by political opportunists who care nothing for proletarian struggles.

Legutko warns liberal-democratic ideology is, in many ways, more frightening than communism, because it is detached from the horrors of communism and thus ignorant of its potential for harmembraces rather than eschews state control, and operates as a “great, liberal-democratic church.” Identity politics excludes universal rights, in the name of equality; it elevates race or sexual preference in status. In the name of multiculturalism, it destroys all culture. In the name of liberty, it coerces all—in speech, thought, and action (what Legutko describes as “coercion to freedom”).

Post-Trump, the left (and even some on the supposed right) are scouring the land for scapegoats—all his supporters are racist, homophobic haters who must be exposed, called out, forced to repent, expelled from positions of authority, lose their jobs, be doxxed. This is the secular shunning from the new Church of Identity. Get on board, or get crushed! Corporate America has joined the fray, including Big Tech’s escalating censorship of political speech. Under what rock is the believer in America and Constitutional law to seek shelter?

Legutko explains this is both the means and ends of today’s liberal ideology: this is as good as it gets. Utopia will never “arrive,” universal rules equally applicable to all will not be established. Instead, this infection will reach deeper into private life, and never be sated with revenge (justice) or satisfactory restitution for infinite past wrongs. It will unravel when it implodes, killing many millions. Like the economist and social theorist Thomas Sowell has long warned, this ideological errancy will create more and more inequities. By focusing on “equity of outcomes,”  this utopian quest will ensure fewer and fewer equalities of opportunity, skewing outcomes yet more, and so on. Perfect equality of outcome is a certain impossibility.

If Americans do not stand and fight this insidious evil today, they will one day be forced to fight it from an underground movement, in hiding. This ideology sweeps past barriers like Constitutionsfreedom of expressionexchange of ideas, or civility. It has no patience, tolerance, time, or respect for such “tools of oppression.” The world must be remade now, the old torn down. (Although, what that world is to become in this new utopia is not disclosed because no one knows—what is “next” will be determined after this round… of purges.)

Americans equipped with these simple truths must stand against utopian dreams that deliver dystopian realities. That horrifying future is now visible, as shameless unjustified attacks against fellow citizens escalate in intensity and scope.

Donald Trump has passed from view, but the virus of New Leftism is thriving and easy to see. And what is visible is that it is a bitter, seething contempt, far wider than any one man.

John Klar is an attorney, farmer, and writer in Vermont’s Green Mountains. He was a 2020 Republican candidate for Vermont Governor, and oversees the nonprofit Vermont Liberty Network. Find him on Twitter at @FarmerJohnKlar, Facebook at John Klar of Vermont, or join John while he feeds his cows and sheep, on Youtube.

Categories: Commentary

9 replies »

  1. The point isn’t whether or not ‘Vermonters’ will fight this insidiousness but rather that there aren’t sufficient numbers of them to offset the majority that’s imposing this tyranny on the others. Again, its like two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch – and it’s you, Mr. Klar, who is on their menu.

    • Whether there are sufficient enough numbers of us, or not, is certainly a valid consideration we must somehow address.

      We know there are good, patriotic Vermonters, who are active, and, there are many who rightly feel disenfranchised to the point of inaction. We need to know how many of these inactive folks are out there, inspire, and motivate them.

  2. Yes, Americans must and I’m confident will fight the insidious evil that is leftism.

    Many good, decent people have long aware that the “live and let live” philosophy is no longer an option. Now, quiet, peaceable people who had hoped to to remain blissfully disengaged are becoming aware that they, too, will have to join the fight.

    What other choice do good people have? We realize the left will continue stupidly and recklessly batting at the beehive until they get a response that they hadn’t bargained for and are psychologically ill-prepared to understand, let alone rebuff.

    As Mr. Klar so well-defined leftism above as “insidious evil,” it is of paramount importance that we understand that we mere mortals cannot fight the supernatural evil influencing, even possessing leftists. We must pray to God for His forgiveness, repent of our sins, and fight under Him.

    To think or act otherwise will result is sure and certain defeat.

    • As always Ala, great post & let’s ALL hope and pray you are right! VERMONT LIVES MATTER!

      • Chief Executive Biden thinks conservatives are a subspecies of archaic humans only capable of “Neanderthal thinking”

    • Alan you are right on target – this is a Biblical Battle and I follow your lead in saying so! The truth will reveal itself – I pray people are ready for it. God is in full charge of this one.

  3. We’re on a crash course with disaster, these existential issues that are being debated in america have dire implications for the future. What people don’t realize is, tech and media have stoked a fire in people and have taken the side of an argument that literally had already rationalized every horror in history against conservatives, anti-lockdown, anti-mask, pro-gun, anti-abortionist, climate skeptic, etc… The conservatives have been dehumanized and media has convinced the left that genocide of freedom and life is totally justified.

    The debate has already taken place, it’s already done, everything oppressive to conservatives justified… Now it’s just a matter of time before they make their next move. I’m not sure when that will be, it could be a ways off still probably will fall in line with the homogenization of china and the US through globalist politics, I digress… But make no mistake it’s inevitable. I’m only wondering if people (enough) are conscientious enough to realize what groups are pushing this…

    • Mr. Smith: They are not. They have all been remarkably easily indoctrinated by higher learning institutions and big tech & fake news.

      My nephew who is an M.D. & instructor at Harvard is now an avowed Socialist, supports closure of ALL prisons, attends Socialist conferences wherein attendees refer to one another as: “Comrade”, etc. etc.

      What we are facing is truly terrifying. ALL my native and/or long-time Vermonters who are democrats believe “hate speech” is actually “a thing.”

  4. “Another commentator, writer and American Unitarian pastor John Pavlovitz, claimed that former President Trump exposed other people’s hate.” This is a great statement by Mr. Klar, as it also exposes their phoney “kindness is everything” for they, the left, do not practice what they preach. If you do not agree with their agendas, they do not utilize kindness. The rudest most dismissive people I’ve ever met are left-wing voters. Their desire to cancel our First Amendment is evidence of these Antifa types’ need to flip the Judeo-Christian, patriarchal-nuclear family&faith over for pagan “free-thinking” socio-political contrary open-borders, “No illegal humans”, communism, legalizing narcotics and free college tuition. These are self-righteous pipedreams missing common sense and real progressive. BLM and BDS are not positive political organizations. But all the hipsters dig burning down American cities and criticizing a country they have never set foot in, Israel.
    Great article!

Leave a Reply to Alan Sexton Cancel reply