(Editor: This guest commentary has been contributed by a Vermont author who wishes to remain anonymous. Today, an exception is made to Vermont Daily’s policy of requiring the identity of authors of published letters, op-eds and news articles, in part because the essay discusses general principles without criticizing individuals.)
This moment in history can only be understood and discussed as a First Amendment constitutional crisis for ALL the several sides. When we begin to thoughtfully approach it as such that will be the beginning of wisdom in the streets. Our Second Amendment is a distraction both sides fail to see beyond for the moment.
BLM is not a movement as much as a phenomenon; instability and misdirection as a campaign tactic. Remember terms like “useful idiots” or “agent provocateurs”? That plus Antifa equals mayhem. The people of the true movement should discipline BLM and Antifa to the larger cause and demand Hope be the paradigm, not destruction. “Burn it down” is not a cause, it is a paradox. History is full of fools and the tyrants who lead them into the streets. History is also filled with wisdom, mass revolt and reform and reluctant prophets who sustain their hopes for change. We choose at our own peril.
BLM should have been a significant side show to a civil rights struggle that is bona fide by any true reading of human history. But BLM is not interested in anything but control and power. Both Rs and Ds have a reason to reign in police brutality but ALSO decades of prosecutorial misconduct. The latter misconduct is actually the primary virus along with its political ally the “war on drugs”. Without lying, bluffing prosecutors the police would have reformed themselves naturally BUT for the war on drugs…. Most cops want to be cops, not henchman.
And prosecutorial misconduct is what led to the “bail to jail to plea bargain pipeline” which results in the mass incarceration of black and brown young men. It is simply easier for cops to feed that supply chain then investigate and intervene at the community level.
Change is not likely at this time. Sorry. Streets and cities will burn. Sorry.
Innocents like George Floyd and Aaron J. Danielson will be murdered and it will be televised… both victims of a people without any wisdom of liberty. Our First Amendment could heal this moment. But I stress both are equally “victims” of this disease and the First Amendment’s complete restoration is the only cure. An entire generation in our streets were never immunized to ignorance and persecution tactics by a thorough knowledge of the true meaning of Liberty as expressed in our Declaration of Independence and the compounded Wisdom that led to our First Amendment being first!
IF Facebook et al, responsible voices from the parties, BLM, Antifa, Trump groups like Patriot Prayer and the like came together and agreed to one simple premise we could have peaceful protests and improved, additional police, mental health and social services.
That premise would be that the shared value for a radical, expansive belief in free speech and press and redress and religious self-determination, AKA the First Amendment. All sides would have to give. But most unlikely to concede ground would be the “cancel culture” and “identity” priests of the temple of 1619 Project, etc. That would mean allowing citizens to demand history and liberty be taught in government schools. A bridge too far I am afraid.
Labor Day 2020
There are three types of peoples; slaves, citizens and tyrants. We are Blessed by God to choose which we will be and which we will serve.
Wm Floyd 1775
Nicely written and presented Peter!
Extensive and extended as this conversation was, I agree that it was a worthwhile exercise. In the final analysis of…
Nor does eveeyone read and re-read and present flawless documents every time they compose a Comment here.
Mr. Evslin take some time – watch reality – check the mans credentials and report back. Everyone welcome to a…
No but faith “is” – different deal all together than Christianity. It has an amazing way of turning darkness into…
Water Cooler: VT demand for vaccines stagnant / paid family, medical leave pushed / hotel room costs climb / Big chair in Bennington damaged
Friday’s hot headlines from Vermont media.
Vermont media have run news stories about Covid-19 skeptics in Oklahoma contracting the disease and now on respirators. But nary a word about Minneapolis missionary Jummai Nache suffered chest pains just three days after her second Pfizer vaccine shot in February. Since then she has suffered blood clots, cardiomyothapy, and amputation of both legs below the knee – with amputation of her hands to follow soon.
Thanks to money garnered by the State of Vermont from a multi-state settlement with Volkswagen over falsified emissions statements, the state’s largest utility has purchased an all-electric power line maintenance bucket truck.