politics

“Liberty and Justice for All” painted next to “Black Lives Matter”?

In appeal for unity, guv candidate Klar asks Montpelier City Council permission to paint flag, words from Pledge of Allegiance in red, white and blue next to BLM street mural

By Guy Page

June 30, 2020 – A candidate for governor has asked the City of Montpelier for permission to paint an American flag and “Liberty and Justice for All” in huge red, white and blue letters next to the “Black Lives Matter” street mural in front of the Vermont State House. 

“We would like to paint ‘Liberty and Justice for All’ for the Independence Day holiday in solidarity with Black Lives Matter,” Republican John Klar said in a special event request submitted June 29 to the City of Montpelier. He wants to “reaffirm the founding principle in our Declaration of Independence that all men are created equal.”

In his request, Klar says his mural “seeks to unify Vermont’s shared goals of racial comity with a slogan that merely reaffirms founding principles.that are now more essential to mutual harmony and respect than ever.”

Klar seeks to paint the new mural Friday, July 3, on State Street between Bailey Avenue and Taylor Street, adjacent and due west of the Black Lives Matter mural painted on State Street Saturday, June 13. 

The BLM mural request was approved unanimously at a Friday, June 12 special meeting of the City Council. Volunteers painted the lengthy street mural the next day. “It’s a quick turnaround here, but with any organizing campaign, you’ve got to feed off the momentum,” City Councilor Conor Casey said. Casey also noted that Gov. Phil Scott had given explicit consent to the BLM mural.

Vermont Daily this morning emailed Mayor Ann Watson and councilors Casey and Dan Richardson, requesting comment and information about how the City will proceed with Klar’s application. As of 1 pm today only Casey was the sole respondent. He said it was the first he had heard of it. 

Klar, of Brookfield, is challenging incumbent Gov. Phil Scott in the August 11 Republican primary. His June 29 letter further explains his request:

“For government to embrace the Black Lives Matter cause but reject an effort to celebrate the Fourth of July and seek to advance common goals towards racial equity would be an inappropriate and unequal application of power,” Klar said. “I submit that Vermont must reaffirm its basic Constitutional principles in this time of economic, social and health anxieties. The goal of the subject event and street painting is to lead Vermonters confidently into a post-Covid normalcy, by reaffirming those values which have helped Vermonters overcome greater challenges than we presently face.”

In the application to the city, Klar said he expects the street painting will need about 25 people and will run from 8 AM to 8 PM. The Klar campaign also has reserved the State House lawn for an Independence Day celebration July 4.

The phrase “Liberty and Justice for all” was coined in 1892 by Rev. Francis Bellamy as the conclusion of the original Pledge of Allegiance. Bellamy – a Baptist fired from one pulpit for his “fiery socialist” views – penned the original Pledge of Allegiance, which was urged for use in all American schools by then-Pres. Benjamin Harrison. The longer, contemporary Pledge of Allegiance was adopted by Pres. Dwight Eisenhower on Flag Day, June 14, 1954.

Google Earth Photo of State Street with proposed street mural photoshopped by Bradford Broyles of News Done Right.

Categories: politics

3 replies »

  1. Hello Guy,

    I want to share an alternative perspective. In the 1950s when we were reciting the line of “liberty and justice for all” in the Pledge to the American flag, we were also accepting segregation and a virtual caste system based upon race. If we can now affirm the truth that on their own, black lives do matter in America, then are we not demonstrating that liberty and justice are truly for all? If elevating the value of a historically marginalized group does not itself exemplify liberty and justice for all, then what exactly is the message being sent by a painted addendum?

    Regards,
    John

  2. Why, exactly, did our governor allow the street in front or our statehouse to be vandalized in the first place? He set a very bad precedent by bowing to belligerent terrorists. Scott is a spineless coward.

Leave a Reply